U.S. federal electricity regulators have scheduled technical conferences for this autumn to discuss issues related to two major policy initiatives: carbon pricing in organized wholesale electricity markets, and offshore wind integration in regional transmission organizations and independent system operators (RTOs/ISOs). The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's scheduling of two technical conferences on these topics signals its interest in exploring the interplay between state energy and environmental policies and federally jurisdictional markets.
One technical conference regarding Carbon Pricing in Organized Wholesale Electricity Markets (Docket No. AD20-14-000)
will be held on September 30, 2020, "to discuss considerations related
to state adoption of mechanisms to price carbon dioxide emissions,
commonly referred to as carbon pricing, in regions with
Commission-jurisdictional organized wholesale electricity markets." The case has its genesis in a request for such an event, filed on April 13, 2020, by a broad coalition including Advanced Energy Economy, the American Council on Renewable Energy, the American Wind Energy Association, Brookfield Renewable, Calpine Corporation, Competitive Power Ventures, Inc., the Electric Power Supply Association, the Independent Power Producers of New York, Inc., LS Power Associates, L.P., the Natural Gas Supply Association, NextEra Energy, Inc., PJM Power Providers Group, R Street Institute, and Vistra Energy Corp. A number of other utilities, RTOs, and state interests also expressed support, prior to the Commission's issuance of a public notice on June 17 scheduling the event.
Another technical conference regarding Offshore Wind Integration in RTOs/ISOs (Docket No. AD20-18-000), to be held October 27, 2020, will be convened "to discuss whether existing Commission transmission, interconnection, and merchant transmission facility frameworks in RTOs/ISOs can accommodate anticipated growth in offshore wind generation in an efficient and effective manner that safeguards open access transmission principles and to consider possible changes or improvements to the current framework should they be needed to accommodate such growth."
Beyond the fact that the Commission issued notices of both technical conferences on June 17, 2020, the proceedings also share a common focus on the effects of state energy and environmental policies on federally-jurisdictional activities. For now, the prevailing carbon pricing mechanisms -- such as the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative adopted by many northeastern states -- and the strongest policies favoring or requiring offshore wind development are arising as a matter of state law and policy, as opposed to federal law.
The boundaries between federal and state jurisdiction are viewed by many as long-settled, although a series of federal court and agency decisions have found specific state electricity procurement and subsidy laws to be preempted by federal regulation, and a case pending before the Commission asks it to find that most state net metering programs are preempted by federal law. Whether the Commission grants or denies the pending request, the June 17 notices of technical conferences on carbon pricing and offshore wind integration suggest continued federal interest in exploring the implications of state policies on FERC-jurisdictional markets.
Showing posts with label wind. Show all posts
Showing posts with label wind. Show all posts
FERC sets carbon pricing and offshore wind tech conferences
Thursday, June 18, 2020
Maine regulators approve long-term contract
Friday, July 19, 2019
Maine utility regulators have approved a long-term contract to purchase the output of a 72.6-megawatt wind power project under development by Weaver Wind, LLC in Hancock County, Maine. The 20-year contract bears a price of 3.5 cents per kilowatt-hour, escalating at 2.5 percent per year.
A Maine statute enacted in 2006 authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to direct investor-owned transmission and distribution utilities to enter into long-term contracts, to the degree necessary to ensure reliability, meet energy efficiency program requirements, or reduce customer costs. In 2008, the Commission used this law to order a contract with the Rollins Wind project. After three subsequent procurement rounds, in 2017 the Commission approved a contract to buy 75 megawatts from Dirigo Solar, LLC, at a price of 3.4 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 20 years.
In response to its most recent solicitation, earlier this year the Commission approved a term sheet for a contract to buy 100 megawatts from Three Rivers Solar Power, LLC’s solar project, with a price of 3.5 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 10 years. Most recently, on July 12, 2019, the Commission approved a contract to buy the output of the Weaver Wind project, also at a price of 3.5 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 10 years.
In addition to this existing law, in 2019 the Maine state legislature enacted several additional long-term contracting programs. One new law creates a new "Class IA" renewable portfolio standard, and requires the procurement by December 31, 2020 of energy or renewable energy credits from Class IA resources sufficient to cover between 7 and 10 percent of Maine's retail electricity sales, with a second round bringing the total procurement to 14 percent of Maine's retail electricity sales. Another new law requires the procurement of 375 megawatts from distributed generation resources between 2020 and 2024, with each project sized at less than 5 megawatts, and specific requirements for participation by non-residential and "community" or shared-ownership projects.
Collectively, these laws create a variety of opportunities for electric power generation projects to compete for and win long-term contracts to sell their output to Maine utilities.
A Maine statute enacted in 2006 authorizes the Public Utilities Commission to direct investor-owned transmission and distribution utilities to enter into long-term contracts, to the degree necessary to ensure reliability, meet energy efficiency program requirements, or reduce customer costs. In 2008, the Commission used this law to order a contract with the Rollins Wind project. After three subsequent procurement rounds, in 2017 the Commission approved a contract to buy 75 megawatts from Dirigo Solar, LLC, at a price of 3.4 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 20 years.
In response to its most recent solicitation, earlier this year the Commission approved a term sheet for a contract to buy 100 megawatts from Three Rivers Solar Power, LLC’s solar project, with a price of 3.5 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 10 years. Most recently, on July 12, 2019, the Commission approved a contract to buy the output of the Weaver Wind project, also at a price of 3.5 cents/kWh escalating at 2.5% annually for 10 years.
In addition to this existing law, in 2019 the Maine state legislature enacted several additional long-term contracting programs. One new law creates a new "Class IA" renewable portfolio standard, and requires the procurement by December 31, 2020 of energy or renewable energy credits from Class IA resources sufficient to cover between 7 and 10 percent of Maine's retail electricity sales, with a second round bringing the total procurement to 14 percent of Maine's retail electricity sales. Another new law requires the procurement of 375 megawatts from distributed generation resources between 2020 and 2024, with each project sized at less than 5 megawatts, and specific requirements for participation by non-residential and "community" or shared-ownership projects.
Collectively, these laws create a variety of opportunities for electric power generation projects to compete for and win long-term contracts to sell their output to Maine utilities.
Labels:
Class IA,
Commission,
Dirigo,
distributed generation,
Hancock County,
Maine,
procurement,
PUC,
Renewable,
Rollins,
RPS,
solar,
solicitation,
Three Rivers,
wind
US ocean energy regulators consider NY-NJ offshore transmission line
Wednesday, July 3, 2019
After receiving a request from a developer of offshore electricity transmission lines for a right-of-way in ocean waters offshore New York and New Jersey, U.S. ocean energy regulators have asked whether any other developers are interested in the same area.
On April 30, 2018, Anbaric Development Partners, LLC (ADP) applied to the federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) for a right-of-way grant for a proposed project called the New York/New Jersey Ocean Grid. As envisioned by ADP, the project would include a submarine system approximately 185 nautical miles in length. It would also include up to 9 offshore collector platforms which would collect and distribute power generated from existing offshore wind leases, each capable of handling 800 to 1,200 megawatts of offshore wind energy, as well as up to 6 onshore landings at locations from Long Island, New York to Cardiff, New Jersey. On June 22, 2018, BOEM approved ADP's legal, technical, and financial qualifications to acquire and hold a Right of Way Grant on the Outer Continental Shelf.
Under BOEM's regulations, different procedures apply depending on whether the agency is following a competitive lease process or a noncompetitive lease award process. ADP's application was "unsolicited," meaning it was not submitted in response to a BOEM solicitation, Request for Interest, or Call for Information and Nominations. Under BOEM's case-by-case process for considering unsolicited requests, the agency will issue a public notice and solicit comments to determine whether competitive interest exists, before considering the application itself. If BOEM determines that competitive interest exists in the requested lease area, BOEM will proceed with its competitive process; otherwise, BOEM will publish a notice of Determination of No Competitive Interest, and may proceed to review the unsolicited lease request.
On June 17, 2019, BOEM announced that it would publish a Request for Competitive Interest for project; the Notice of Proposed Grant Area and Request for Competitive Interest was published in the Federal Register on June 19, 2019. Indications of interest in acquiring a right-of-way grant for the area ADP requested must be sent by mail, postmarked no later than July 19, 2019, to be considered. Comments or other information may be sent by mail, postmarked by the same date, or may be submitted through the Federal Rulemaking Portal at http://www.regulations.gov.
If BOEM receives indications of competitive interest from qualified entities, the bureau may decide to move forward with the right-of-way grant issuance process using competitive procedures. BOEM will continue to consult with the state task force and partners regarding the proposed transmission project.
As an increasing number of states and utilities are procuring offshore wind, functions that must be provided include collecting the power produced, transmitting it to shore, and integrating it into the onshore grid. Depending on their design and configuration, offshore transmission grids could play these roles, and could also help wheel power along the coastline from one region to another. Questions of cost recovery -- who pays for these systems -- will continue to arise, at the intersection between state policies calling for offshore wind and regional markets rooted in economics.
On April 30, 2018, Anbaric Development Partners, LLC (ADP) applied to the federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) for a right-of-way grant for a proposed project called the New York/New Jersey Ocean Grid. As envisioned by ADP, the project would include a submarine system approximately 185 nautical miles in length. It would also include up to 9 offshore collector platforms which would collect and distribute power generated from existing offshore wind leases, each capable of handling 800 to 1,200 megawatts of offshore wind energy, as well as up to 6 onshore landings at locations from Long Island, New York to Cardiff, New Jersey. On June 22, 2018, BOEM approved ADP's legal, technical, and financial qualifications to acquire and hold a Right of Way Grant on the Outer Continental Shelf.
Under BOEM's regulations, different procedures apply depending on whether the agency is following a competitive lease process or a noncompetitive lease award process. ADP's application was "unsolicited," meaning it was not submitted in response to a BOEM solicitation, Request for Interest, or Call for Information and Nominations. Under BOEM's case-by-case process for considering unsolicited requests, the agency will issue a public notice and solicit comments to determine whether competitive interest exists, before considering the application itself. If BOEM determines that competitive interest exists in the requested lease area, BOEM will proceed with its competitive process; otherwise, BOEM will publish a notice of Determination of No Competitive Interest, and may proceed to review the unsolicited lease request.
On June 17, 2019, BOEM announced that it would publish a Request for Competitive Interest for project; the Notice of Proposed Grant Area and Request for Competitive Interest was published in the Federal Register on June 19, 2019. Indications of interest in acquiring a right-of-way grant for the area ADP requested must be sent by mail, postmarked no later than July 19, 2019, to be considered. Comments or other information may be sent by mail, postmarked by the same date, or may be submitted through the Federal Rulemaking Portal at http://www.regulations.gov.
If BOEM receives indications of competitive interest from qualified entities, the bureau may decide to move forward with the right-of-way grant issuance process using competitive procedures. BOEM will continue to consult with the state task force and partners regarding the proposed transmission project.
As an increasing number of states and utilities are procuring offshore wind, functions that must be provided include collecting the power produced, transmitting it to shore, and integrating it into the onshore grid. Depending on their design and configuration, offshore transmission grids could play these roles, and could also help wheel power along the coastline from one region to another. Questions of cost recovery -- who pays for these systems -- will continue to arise, at the intersection between state policies calling for offshore wind and regional markets rooted in economics.
Labels:
BOEM,
Call,
comment,
competitive,
cost recovery,
market,
Ocean,
offshore,
state,
transmission,
wind
FERC upholds Block Island offshore wind PPA
Tuesday, April 30, 2019
Federal energy regulators have denied a complaint by a Newport, Rhode Island city councilor against state regulators' approval of a power purchase agreement for an offshore wind project off Block Island.
At issue is Deepwater Wind Block Island, LLC's small-scale 30-megawatt offshore wind project located near Rhode Island's Block Island. The project sells its output to utility Narragansett Electric Company, Inc. d/b/a National Grid (National Grid), pursuant to a power purchase agreement approved by the Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission on August 16, 2010.
On June 7, 2018, Ms. Kathryn E. Leonard filed a complaint to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, alleging that the implementation of the power purchase agreement violated various federal laws, including the Federal Power Act, Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA), and the Supremacy and Interstate Commerce Clauses of the U.S. Constitution.
On April 24, 2019, the Commission issued its order denying Ms. Leonard's complaint. In the seventeen-page order, the Commission noted that the complainant provided no evidence in support of her assertion that the power purchase agreement was entered into pursuant to Rhode Island's implementation of PURPA. Instead, the Commission found that the Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission's approval of the contract was pursuant to state law, not pursuant to its PURPA regulations -- but that even if it were pursuant to PURPA, federal regulations governing sales by qualifying facilities to electric utilities explicitly permit negotiated rates.
The Commission similarly found that the complainant failed to show that the contract or its pricing was unjust and unreasonable under the Federal Power Act, and to provide sufficient support for its constitutional claims. The Commission also distinguished the Block Island PPA from contracts it previously invalidated in another case, Hughes v. Talen, which involved contracts for differences and an explicit requirement of participation in the capacity market. For these reasons, the Commission denied the complaint.
The Block Island project is the first commercially-operating offshore wind project in the United States. A number of other projects are currently under development, and several states in the Northeast have enacted laws requiring utility procurement of offshore wind energy. According to a 2016 analysis by the U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. offshore wind has a technical resource potential of more than 2,000 gigawatts of capacity, or 7,200 terawatt-hours of generation per year -- nearly twice the nation’s current electricity use.
At issue is Deepwater Wind Block Island, LLC's small-scale 30-megawatt offshore wind project located near Rhode Island's Block Island. The project sells its output to utility Narragansett Electric Company, Inc. d/b/a National Grid (National Grid), pursuant to a power purchase agreement approved by the Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission on August 16, 2010.
On June 7, 2018, Ms. Kathryn E. Leonard filed a complaint to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, alleging that the implementation of the power purchase agreement violated various federal laws, including the Federal Power Act, Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA), and the Supremacy and Interstate Commerce Clauses of the U.S. Constitution.
On April 24, 2019, the Commission issued its order denying Ms. Leonard's complaint. In the seventeen-page order, the Commission noted that the complainant provided no evidence in support of her assertion that the power purchase agreement was entered into pursuant to Rhode Island's implementation of PURPA. Instead, the Commission found that the Rhode Island Public Utilities Commission's approval of the contract was pursuant to state law, not pursuant to its PURPA regulations -- but that even if it were pursuant to PURPA, federal regulations governing sales by qualifying facilities to electric utilities explicitly permit negotiated rates.
The Commission similarly found that the complainant failed to show that the contract or its pricing was unjust and unreasonable under the Federal Power Act, and to provide sufficient support for its constitutional claims. The Commission also distinguished the Block Island PPA from contracts it previously invalidated in another case, Hughes v. Talen, which involved contracts for differences and an explicit requirement of participation in the capacity market. For these reasons, the Commission denied the complaint.
The Block Island project is the first commercially-operating offshore wind project in the United States. A number of other projects are currently under development, and several states in the Northeast have enacted laws requiring utility procurement of offshore wind energy. According to a 2016 analysis by the U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. offshore wind has a technical resource potential of more than 2,000 gigawatts of capacity, or 7,200 terawatt-hours of generation per year -- nearly twice the nation’s current electricity use.
Labels:
Block Island,
capacity,
Commerce Clause,
complaint,
deepwater wind,
FERC,
FPA,
Hughes,
offshore,
PPA,
procurement,
PURPA,
Rhode Island,
Supremacy Clause,
wind
New England 2019 Regional Energy Outlook describes shifts, challenges
Thursday, March 21, 2019
New England's electricity system is shifting toward a "hybrid grid," according to the operator of New England's wholesale electricity markets and electric transmission system. A recent report by ISO New England, Inc. describes the electric sector's transition towards generating resources with lower carbon emissions and the resulting implications for the environment and the economy.
ISO New England is the federally-designated regional transmission organization serving New England. The grid operator recently released its 2019 Regional Energy Outlook, a document described as “one of the many ways the ISO keeps stakeholders informed about the current state of the grid, issues affecting its future, and ISO initiatives to ensure a modern, reliable power system for New England.”
In the report, ISO New England emphasizes the region’s decarbonization and shifting resource mix, noting that “carbon emissions from the grid have fallen by roughly a third... the region is on its way from having an electric grid dominated by fossil-fuel and nuclear generation to one that includes large amounts of wind and hydro generation and hundreds of thousands of small solar and storage systems spanning the six states. The states’ next step in their decarbonization journey is to transition the emissions-heavy heating and transportation sectors to low-carbon electricity.”
ISO-NE describes the way these changes are happening as “challenging reliable system operations and competitive wholesale electricity markets.” ISO says that “for the foreseeable future, the region will remain vulnerable to energy shortfalls and wholesale price volatility as more and more resources with limited-energy ‘inventories’ (natural gas generation, wind, solar, battery storage) displace resources with on-site fuel that can sustain operation for extended periods (oil, coal, nuclear, dual-fuel generation).”
ISO New England says its competitive markets weren’t designed to telegraph future energy scarcity conditions, compensate resources for fuel inventory, achieve carbon reduction goals, or specifically lead to renewable development. It notes that state-sponsored resources suppress market prices when in markets, but would lead to overbuild if outside markets. ISO advocates, “Establishing a realistic price on carbon remains a more seamless and simpler way to achieve clean-energy goals through markets without distorting competition, but this is not in the ISO’s jurisdiction. State or federal policymakers could pursue this direction but have not done so to date.” ISO notes, “Nuclear resources will prove critical to meeting both decarbonization and energy-security goals for years to come, but how they can remain financially viable is still unclear.”
ISO-NE says it is focused on 3 elements to support the transition to the “hybrid grid”: supporting the rapid transformation of the region’s electricity supply and demand mix, maintaining a robust transmission system, and ensuring energy security.
The grid operator also noted limitations on what tools it can use to address these challenges: “Importantly, ISO New England does not have the authority to dictate investments in energy infrastructure that can help ensure that the region’s energy needs can be met in all seasons, under all conditions. Our toolkit is to create financial stimuli through the wholesale electricity markets that will drive action. Opposition or impediments to infrastructure decisions will only exacerbate the region’s energy-security constraints.”
ISO New England is the federally-designated regional transmission organization serving New England. The grid operator recently released its 2019 Regional Energy Outlook, a document described as “one of the many ways the ISO keeps stakeholders informed about the current state of the grid, issues affecting its future, and ISO initiatives to ensure a modern, reliable power system for New England.”
In the report, ISO New England emphasizes the region’s decarbonization and shifting resource mix, noting that “carbon emissions from the grid have fallen by roughly a third... the region is on its way from having an electric grid dominated by fossil-fuel and nuclear generation to one that includes large amounts of wind and hydro generation and hundreds of thousands of small solar and storage systems spanning the six states. The states’ next step in their decarbonization journey is to transition the emissions-heavy heating and transportation sectors to low-carbon electricity.”
ISO-NE describes the way these changes are happening as “challenging reliable system operations and competitive wholesale electricity markets.” ISO says that “for the foreseeable future, the region will remain vulnerable to energy shortfalls and wholesale price volatility as more and more resources with limited-energy ‘inventories’ (natural gas generation, wind, solar, battery storage) displace resources with on-site fuel that can sustain operation for extended periods (oil, coal, nuclear, dual-fuel generation).”
ISO New England says its competitive markets weren’t designed to telegraph future energy scarcity conditions, compensate resources for fuel inventory, achieve carbon reduction goals, or specifically lead to renewable development. It notes that state-sponsored resources suppress market prices when in markets, but would lead to overbuild if outside markets. ISO advocates, “Establishing a realistic price on carbon remains a more seamless and simpler way to achieve clean-energy goals through markets without distorting competition, but this is not in the ISO’s jurisdiction. State or federal policymakers could pursue this direction but have not done so to date.” ISO notes, “Nuclear resources will prove critical to meeting both decarbonization and energy-security goals for years to come, but how they can remain financially viable is still unclear.”
ISO-NE says it is focused on 3 elements to support the transition to the “hybrid grid”: supporting the rapid transformation of the region’s electricity supply and demand mix, maintaining a robust transmission system, and ensuring energy security.
The grid operator also noted limitations on what tools it can use to address these challenges: “Importantly, ISO New England does not have the authority to dictate investments in energy infrastructure that can help ensure that the region’s energy needs can be met in all seasons, under all conditions. Our toolkit is to create financial stimuli through the wholesale electricity markets that will drive action. Opposition or impediments to infrastructure decisions will only exacerbate the region’s energy-security constraints.”
Federal auction set for Massachusetts offshore wind leases
Wednesday, November 7, 2018
The federal agency responsible for managing ocean energy development on the Outer Continental Shelf has scheduled an auction for about 390,000 acres offshore Massachusetts, to be held on December 13, 2018.
Under federal law, the U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management is responsible for conducting auctions to lease parcels of federal waters for offshore wind energy development.
On October 17, Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke announced that BOEM will hold its next offshore wind auction in December. According to the Final Sale Notice published in the Federal Register on October 19, the agency will hold its Atlantic Wind Lease Sale 4A, covering 388,569 acres offshore Massachusetts. The sale will cover three separate leases, located within an area previously offered but unsold in 2015.
Nineteen companies have qualified to participate as bidders in the lease sale:
Under federal law, the U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management is responsible for conducting auctions to lease parcels of federal waters for offshore wind energy development.
On October 17, Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke announced that BOEM will hold its next offshore wind auction in December. According to the Final Sale Notice published in the Federal Register on October 19, the agency will hold its Atlantic Wind Lease Sale 4A, covering 388,569 acres offshore Massachusetts. The sale will cover three separate leases, located within an area previously offered but unsold in 2015.
![]() |
| BOEM map of the proposed lease areas available through the December 2018 auction. |
Nineteen companies have qualified to participate as bidders in the lease sale:
- Avangrid Renewables, LLC
- Camellia Wind Energy LLC
- CI III Blue Cloud Wind Energy II LLC
- Cobra Industrial Services, Inc.
- Deepwater Wind New England, LLC
- East Wind LLC
- EC&R Development, LLC
- EDF Renewables Development, Inc.
- EDPR Offshore North America LLC
- Enbridge Holdings (Green Energy) L.L.C.
- Innogy US Renewable Projects LLC
- Mayflower Wind Energy LLC
- Northeast Wind Energy LLC
- Northland Power America Inc .
- PNE WIND USA, Inc.
- Equinor Wind US LLC
- Vineyard Wind LLC
- Wind Future LLC
- wpd offshore Alpha LLC
BOEM proposes Massachusetts offshore wind lease auction
Tuesday, April 10, 2018
U.S. ocean energy regulators have announced the proposed lease sale of two new areas offshore Massachusetts for commercial wind energy leasing, totaling about 390,000 acres.
On April 6, 2018, U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke announced that the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management would publish a Proposed Sale Notice for Commercial Leasing for Wind Power on the Outer Continental Shelf Offshore Massachusetts on April 11, 2018.
Through that Proposed Sale Notice, BOEM described its plans to conduct Atlantic Wind Lease Sale 4A. That auction would offer two lease areas offshore Massachusetts for potential commercial wind energy development: Lease OCS-A 0502 consisting of 248,015 acres, and Lease OCS-A 0503 consisting of 140,554 acres. These lease areas were previously offered in 2015, but were not sold.
The Proposed Sale Notice solicits reaffirmations of continued interest from previously qualified prospective bidders -- including 11 entities that qualified to participate in the 2015 Massachusetts lease sale. It also solicits qualification packages from any prospective bidders that BOEM has not previously qualified for a Massachusetts lease sale. The proposal also comes with a 60-day public comment period.
Following the public comment period, if BOEM proceeds with the Massachusetts lease auction, the agency will eventually publish a Final Sale Notice announcing the time and date of the lease sale.
To date, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has awarded 13 commercial offshore wind leases, including sites off every state from Massachusetts to North Carolina.
On April 6, 2018, U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke announced that the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management would publish a Proposed Sale Notice for Commercial Leasing for Wind Power on the Outer Continental Shelf Offshore Massachusetts on April 11, 2018.
Through that Proposed Sale Notice, BOEM described its plans to conduct Atlantic Wind Lease Sale 4A. That auction would offer two lease areas offshore Massachusetts for potential commercial wind energy development: Lease OCS-A 0502 consisting of 248,015 acres, and Lease OCS-A 0503 consisting of 140,554 acres. These lease areas were previously offered in 2015, but were not sold.
The Proposed Sale Notice solicits reaffirmations of continued interest from previously qualified prospective bidders -- including 11 entities that qualified to participate in the 2015 Massachusetts lease sale. It also solicits qualification packages from any prospective bidders that BOEM has not previously qualified for a Massachusetts lease sale. The proposal also comes with a 60-day public comment period.
Following the public comment period, if BOEM proceeds with the Massachusetts lease auction, the agency will eventually publish a Final Sale Notice announcing the time and date of the lease sale.
To date, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has awarded 13 commercial offshore wind leases, including sites off every state from Massachusetts to North Carolina.
FERC Order 842 requires primary frequency response by generators
Monday, March 12, 2018
U.S. energy regulators have issued an order amending standard interconnection agreements to require new generators to install, maintain and operate a functioning governor or equivalent controls capable of primary frequency response as a precondition of interconnection. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's Order No. 842 also amended the pro forma interconnection agreements to include certain operating requirements including maximum droop and deadband parameters, and sustained response provisions.
As described by the Commission, reliable operation of an alternating current grid requires maintaining system frequency within predetermined boundaries above and below 60 Hertz. Frequency response describes an interconnected grid’s ability to arrest and stabilize deviations from this predetermined range of frequencies after a sudden loss of generation or load.
Historically, the U.S. grid's primary frequency response capability came from baseload synchronous generators such as coal-fired power plants. But many such plants have retired in recent years, with further retirements expected. In 2016, the Commission noted that shifts in the portfolio of U.S. electric generators meant fewer resources could likely provide primary frequency response, especially if new variable energy resources such as wind and solar did not provide this service. In response, it opened an inquiry into what primary frequency response reforms it should make.
On February 15, 2018, the Commission issued its Order No. 842 revising its regulations to require newly interconnecting large and small generating facilities, both synchronous and non-synchronous, to install, maintain, and operate equipment capable of providing primary frequency response as a condition of interconnection. The final rule also amends the Commission's pro forma interconnection agreements to include certain operating requirements including maximum droop and deadband parameters, and sustained response provisions. It provides exemptions for nuclear power plants and some combined heat-and-power plants.
These requirements will apply to most newly interconnecting generation facilities that execute, or request the unexecuted filing of, an LGIA or SGIA on or after the rule’s effective date, as well as to existing large and small generating facilities that take any action that requires the submission of a new interconnection request that results in the filing of an executed or unexecuted interconnection agreement on or after the effective date.
In a press release, the Commission said its action was intended to address "the increasing impact of the evolving generation resource mix." Commissioner LaFleur made a separate statement in which she noted that while decreases in the nation's portfolio percentage of synchronous generation have contributed to declining frequency response performance, "recent technological advancements have enabled new non-synchronous generating facilities, such as wind and solar, to cost-effectively include primary frequency response capabilities in their facilities." Improved inverters and battery storage are among these innovations.
The Commission has also recently noted the potential of electric storage resources to provide frequency response and other services. Its Order No. 841 is designed to remove barriers to the participation of electric storage resources in wholesale markets operated by regional transmission organization and independent system operators, including markets for frequency response.
As described by the Commission, reliable operation of an alternating current grid requires maintaining system frequency within predetermined boundaries above and below 60 Hertz. Frequency response describes an interconnected grid’s ability to arrest and stabilize deviations from this predetermined range of frequencies after a sudden loss of generation or load.
Historically, the U.S. grid's primary frequency response capability came from baseload synchronous generators such as coal-fired power plants. But many such plants have retired in recent years, with further retirements expected. In 2016, the Commission noted that shifts in the portfolio of U.S. electric generators meant fewer resources could likely provide primary frequency response, especially if new variable energy resources such as wind and solar did not provide this service. In response, it opened an inquiry into what primary frequency response reforms it should make.
On February 15, 2018, the Commission issued its Order No. 842 revising its regulations to require newly interconnecting large and small generating facilities, both synchronous and non-synchronous, to install, maintain, and operate equipment capable of providing primary frequency response as a condition of interconnection. The final rule also amends the Commission's pro forma interconnection agreements to include certain operating requirements including maximum droop and deadband parameters, and sustained response provisions. It provides exemptions for nuclear power plants and some combined heat-and-power plants.
These requirements will apply to most newly interconnecting generation facilities that execute, or request the unexecuted filing of, an LGIA or SGIA on or after the rule’s effective date, as well as to existing large and small generating facilities that take any action that requires the submission of a new interconnection request that results in the filing of an executed or unexecuted interconnection agreement on or after the effective date.
In a press release, the Commission said its action was intended to address "the increasing impact of the evolving generation resource mix." Commissioner LaFleur made a separate statement in which she noted that while decreases in the nation's portfolio percentage of synchronous generation have contributed to declining frequency response performance, "recent technological advancements have enabled new non-synchronous generating facilities, such as wind and solar, to cost-effectively include primary frequency response capabilities in their facilities." Improved inverters and battery storage are among these innovations.
The Commission has also recently noted the potential of electric storage resources to provide frequency response and other services. Its Order No. 841 is designed to remove barriers to the participation of electric storage resources in wholesale markets operated by regional transmission organization and independent system operators, including markets for frequency response.
Labels:
841,
842,
coal,
FERC,
frequency,
frequency response,
governor,
interconnection,
LGIA,
order,
portfolio,
retirement,
SGIA,
solar,
wind
ISO-NE 2018 Regional Electricity Outlook
Thursday, February 15, 2018
Regional electricity grid operator ISO New England, Inc. has released its 2018 Regional Electricity Outlook. According to the report, "the biggest challenge to the
reliability of the grid is the lack of fuel infrastructure to supply the fleet of natural-gas-fired generators,
further emission restrictions on oil-fired generation, and the reality that older oil and nuclear generators
are becoming less economically competitive and may retire before the region has added sufficient new
energy sources to replace them."
The report cites competitive forces has having "unleashed new approaches for producing electricity in a cleaner way and integrating technology that enables different types of resources to participate in the wholesale markets." It notes new resource types entering the wholesale market, including demand resources, and fast-responding energy storage devices.
With respect to energy supply, the 2018 outlook notes that the amount of wind and solar power in New England continues to grow "and is making a difference in how the ISO operates the power system and designs the wholesale markets." In 2017, the amount of new wind power seeking interconnection in New England surpassed proposed new natural-gas-fired generation for the first time, including significant amounts in Maine and offshore of Massachusetts.
On the demand side, it notes that significant investments in solar resources and energy-efficiency measures have moderated demand for wholesale electricity, but that electrifying the transportation and heating sectors to reduce their carbon emissions could lead to increased demand.
ISO-NE has previously identified the risk that power plants will run out of fuel as the foremost challenge to a reliable power grid in New England. Last month, ISO-NE released an operational fuel security study analyzing fuel security risks facing region's power plants under a wide range of hypothetical future scenarios. That report concluded that maintaining the electric grid's reliability "is likely to become more challenging, especially if current power system trends continue."
The 2018 Regional Electricity Outlook notes that while ISO-NE plays a role in addressing regional fuel-delivery constraints, "it will be up to market participants and state officials to take actions to secure forward fuel arrangements or bolster supply- or demand-side infrastructure." The report identifies potentially appropriate investments as including "enhancements to natural gas infrastructure or the supply chains for liquefied natural gas and oil; relaxation of rules to allow easier permitting and operation of dual-fuel resources; investments in even more renewable energy and any transmission needed to deliver it; or further measures to significantly reduce demand on the power system or the gas system," or some combination of these.
While reliability is core to the grid operator's priorities, the report acknowledges that New England's policymakers, businesses and citizens also value economic and environmental goals. The report specifically highlighted what it called "the reliability, economic, and environmental consequences of our situation: that regional action to resolve fuel-security risks will involve costly infrastructure investments and perhaps the retention of certain critical energy resources, but inaction will also come with a bill for high energy prices when energy supply is constrained—as well as the potential for greater risks to power system reliability and higher emissions."
The report cites competitive forces has having "unleashed new approaches for producing electricity in a cleaner way and integrating technology that enables different types of resources to participate in the wholesale markets." It notes new resource types entering the wholesale market, including demand resources, and fast-responding energy storage devices.
With respect to energy supply, the 2018 outlook notes that the amount of wind and solar power in New England continues to grow "and is making a difference in how the ISO operates the power system and designs the wholesale markets." In 2017, the amount of new wind power seeking interconnection in New England surpassed proposed new natural-gas-fired generation for the first time, including significant amounts in Maine and offshore of Massachusetts.
On the demand side, it notes that significant investments in solar resources and energy-efficiency measures have moderated demand for wholesale electricity, but that electrifying the transportation and heating sectors to reduce their carbon emissions could lead to increased demand.
ISO-NE has previously identified the risk that power plants will run out of fuel as the foremost challenge to a reliable power grid in New England. Last month, ISO-NE released an operational fuel security study analyzing fuel security risks facing region's power plants under a wide range of hypothetical future scenarios. That report concluded that maintaining the electric grid's reliability "is likely to become more challenging, especially if current power system trends continue."
The 2018 Regional Electricity Outlook notes that while ISO-NE plays a role in addressing regional fuel-delivery constraints, "it will be up to market participants and state officials to take actions to secure forward fuel arrangements or bolster supply- or demand-side infrastructure." The report identifies potentially appropriate investments as including "enhancements to natural gas infrastructure or the supply chains for liquefied natural gas and oil; relaxation of rules to allow easier permitting and operation of dual-fuel resources; investments in even more renewable energy and any transmission needed to deliver it; or further measures to significantly reduce demand on the power system or the gas system," or some combination of these.
While reliability is core to the grid operator's priorities, the report acknowledges that New England's policymakers, businesses and citizens also value economic and environmental goals. The report specifically highlighted what it called "the reliability, economic, and environmental consequences of our situation: that regional action to resolve fuel-security risks will involve costly infrastructure investments and perhaps the retention of certain critical energy resources, but inaction will also come with a bill for high energy prices when energy supply is constrained—as well as the potential for greater risks to power system reliability and higher emissions."
Labels:
demand,
emissions,
fuel security,
ISO-NE,
LNG,
natural gas,
New England,
oil,
PV,
reliability,
report,
retirement,
solar,
supply,
wholesale,
wind
NH SEC denies Northern Pass certificate
Thursday, February 1, 2018
The New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee has unanimously voted to deny an application to develop a major new electric transmission line across that state, according to an article in the Union Leader. According to that article, the Committee felt the Northern Pass Transmission developer had not satisfied its burden under state law to show that the line's development would not
“unduly interfere with the orderly development of the region.”
Northern Pass Transmission, LLC has proposed a 192-mile transmission line project capable of bringing 1,090 megawatts of power into New England. The project includes a new direct current (DC) transmission line from the Canadian border to a new converter terminal to be built in Franklin, New Hampshire, as well as a new AC transmission line connecting to the existing grid at a substation in Deerfield.
To develop the project, the developer needs approval from the New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee in the form of a Certificate of Site and Facility. Northern Pass applied to the SEC for a certificate in 2015; the case before the Committee has been ongoing since then, with extensive testimony and hearings held last month.
Successful project development involves not just securing all required permits, but also finding or creating suitable commercial arrangements. While the project's siting application was pending, the project won some commercial success last week, when a group of Massachusetts utilities seeking to jointly procure clean electricity selected a Northern Pass-affiliated proposal to supply about 9,450,000 megawatt-hours per year from Canada. After reviewing over 40 bids, the bid committee selected the "Northern Pass Transmission, Hydro" option for negotiation of a final long-term power sales agreement under the state's Section 83D clean energy contracting program.
Today's decision by the New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee relates directly to siting, not to commercial matters. The developer may be able to challenge the Committee's permitting decision. In the meantime, could the SEC decision affect the Northern Pass project's commercial fate? According to the Massachusetts 83D website, "If the bid selected to advance to contract negotiation at this stage does not successfully negotiate contracts, it may result in other bid(s) being selected to advance to contract negotiations." If the lack of SEC approval (for now) means Northern Pass does not successfully negotiate contracts with the Massachusetts utilities, it could open the door for other 83D bidders to move forward.
Northern Pass Transmission, LLC has proposed a 192-mile transmission line project capable of bringing 1,090 megawatts of power into New England. The project includes a new direct current (DC) transmission line from the Canadian border to a new converter terminal to be built in Franklin, New Hampshire, as well as a new AC transmission line connecting to the existing grid at a substation in Deerfield.
To develop the project, the developer needs approval from the New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee in the form of a Certificate of Site and Facility. Northern Pass applied to the SEC for a certificate in 2015; the case before the Committee has been ongoing since then, with extensive testimony and hearings held last month.
Successful project development involves not just securing all required permits, but also finding or creating suitable commercial arrangements. While the project's siting application was pending, the project won some commercial success last week, when a group of Massachusetts utilities seeking to jointly procure clean electricity selected a Northern Pass-affiliated proposal to supply about 9,450,000 megawatt-hours per year from Canada. After reviewing over 40 bids, the bid committee selected the "Northern Pass Transmission, Hydro" option for negotiation of a final long-term power sales agreement under the state's Section 83D clean energy contracting program.
Today's decision by the New Hampshire Site Evaluation Committee relates directly to siting, not to commercial matters. The developer may be able to challenge the Committee's permitting decision. In the meantime, could the SEC decision affect the Northern Pass project's commercial fate? According to the Massachusetts 83D website, "If the bid selected to advance to contract negotiation at this stage does not successfully negotiate contracts, it may result in other bid(s) being selected to advance to contract negotiations." If the lack of SEC approval (for now) means Northern Pass does not successfully negotiate contracts with the Massachusetts utilities, it could open the door for other 83D bidders to move forward.
Labels:
83D,
Canada,
certificate,
converter station,
HVDC,
hydro,
long-term contract,
NH,
Northern Pass,
PPA,
SEC,
siting,
transmission,
wind
Guajataca Dam, spillway erosion, and repairs
Friday, October 6, 2017
As Puerto Rico continues to grapple with the aftermath of Hurricane Maria, information on damage to the Guajataca Dam remains scarce, while reports suggest spillway repairs may be ongoing.
Hurricane Maria made landfall in Puerto Rico last month, bringing 150 mph winds and 20 inches of rain. Damage to infrastructure was widespread, and the destruction of electricity and communications networks hindered efforts to assess the damage and move toward recovery.
Early reports suggested that the Guajataca Dam had "failed". On September 22, the National Weather Service's San Juan office tweeted an alert of a "flash flood emergency for a dam failure" at the Guajataca Dam and noted ongoing evacuations.
But as reported by Vox on September 30, an Army Corps spokesman said that the dam was not breached and "has not failed and not collapsed." The article described damage to the dam's overflow spillway.
According to a Department of Defense posting dated October 1, 2017, the Defense Department has deployed more response capacity to Puerto Rico, while the Guajataca Dam spillway continued to erode. The Defense Department said U.S. Transportation Command delivered 900 super sandbags for spillway stabilization to Aguadilla Airport on September 30, and that spillway sandbag installation by the Army Corps of Engineers would start on October 1 and will be complete by October 2.
An article posted by The Independent on October 4 describes the Army Corps' use of Osprey V2 rotor-tilt heavy-lift aircraft to drop concrete barriers from the dam into the spillway, in an attempt to limit further erosion of the spillway channel. The article says the "channel has suffered serious erosion as much of its cement cladding was washed away."
Dam safety and flood control spillway damage have featured prominently in recent news. California's Oroville Dam's spillway was damaged earlier this year, including a concrete failure on the lower chute of the gated flood control spillway, severe erosion under the gated spillway, and erosion in the areas on the hillside beneath the emergency spillway. According to the California Department of Water Resources, repairs at Oroville Dam will remain ongoing into 2018 or beyond.
Hurricane Maria made landfall in Puerto Rico last month, bringing 150 mph winds and 20 inches of rain. Damage to infrastructure was widespread, and the destruction of electricity and communications networks hindered efforts to assess the damage and move toward recovery.
Early reports suggested that the Guajataca Dam had "failed". On September 22, the National Weather Service's San Juan office tweeted an alert of a "flash flood emergency for a dam failure" at the Guajataca Dam and noted ongoing evacuations.
But as reported by Vox on September 30, an Army Corps spokesman said that the dam was not breached and "has not failed and not collapsed." The article described damage to the dam's overflow spillway.
According to a Department of Defense posting dated October 1, 2017, the Defense Department has deployed more response capacity to Puerto Rico, while the Guajataca Dam spillway continued to erode. The Defense Department said U.S. Transportation Command delivered 900 super sandbags for spillway stabilization to Aguadilla Airport on September 30, and that spillway sandbag installation by the Army Corps of Engineers would start on October 1 and will be complete by October 2.
An article posted by The Independent on October 4 describes the Army Corps' use of Osprey V2 rotor-tilt heavy-lift aircraft to drop concrete barriers from the dam into the spillway, in an attempt to limit further erosion of the spillway channel. The article says the "channel has suffered serious erosion as much of its cement cladding was washed away."
Dam safety and flood control spillway damage have featured prominently in recent news. California's Oroville Dam's spillway was damaged earlier this year, including a concrete failure on the lower chute of the gated flood control spillway, severe erosion under the gated spillway, and erosion in the areas on the hillside beneath the emergency spillway. According to the California Department of Water Resources, repairs at Oroville Dam will remain ongoing into 2018 or beyond.
Labels:
Army Corps,
dam failure,
dam safety,
erosion,
flood,
Hurricane Maria,
Oroville,
Puerto Rico,
spillway,
wind
Massachusetts offshore wind RFP
Tuesday, July 11, 2017
Massachusetts' investor-owned electric distribution companies have issued a joint Request for Proposals for offshore wind energy projects. Through the RFP, the utilities seek proposals for 400 megawatts (or more) of qualifying offshore wind energy generation and associated transmission, with winning bidders earning 15- to 20-year long-term contracts to sell project power. This Massachusetts offshore wind RFP is designed as the first step in a staggered procurement schedule for compliance with a 2016 state law requiring the utilities to contract for 1,600 MW of aggregate nameplate capacity of offshore renewable generation by June 30, 2027.
In 2016, the Massachusetts legislature enacted the Energy Diversity Act, adding a new Section 83C to the Green Communities Act. Section 83C provides in relevant part, "In order to facilitate the financing of offshore wind energy generation resources in the commonwealth, not later than June 30, 2017, every distribution company shall jointly and competitively solicit proposals for offshore wind energy generation; and, provided, that reasonable proposals have been received, shall enter into cost-effective long-term contracts."
The pending RFP is the first joint solicitation under Section 83C. Through the RFP, the distribution companies are seeking to procure a total of approximately 400 MW of Offshore Wind Energy Generation. The RFP defines this term as:
Pursuant to the Department of Public Utilities order approving the solicitation process, projects will be selected for negotiation by April 23, 2018, with contracts submitted for Department approval no later than July 31, 2018.
In 2016, the Massachusetts legislature enacted the Energy Diversity Act, adding a new Section 83C to the Green Communities Act. Section 83C provides in relevant part, "In order to facilitate the financing of offshore wind energy generation resources in the commonwealth, not later than June 30, 2017, every distribution company shall jointly and competitively solicit proposals for offshore wind energy generation; and, provided, that reasonable proposals have been received, shall enter into cost-effective long-term contracts."
The pending RFP is the first joint solicitation under Section 83C. Through the RFP, the distribution companies are seeking to procure a total of approximately 400 MW of Offshore Wind Energy Generation. The RFP defines this term as:
offshore electric generating resources derived from wind that: (1) are Class I renewable energy generating sources, as defined in Section 11F of Chapter 25A of the General Laws; (2) have a commercial operations date on or after January 1, 2018, that has been verified by the Department of Energy Resources; and (3) operate in a designated wind energy area for which an initial federal lease was issued on a competitive basis after January 1, 2012.Bids are due by noon EDT on December 20, 2017. The RFP prescribes a three-stage review process, including an initial eligibility and threshold screening, subsequent qualitative and quantitative review, and finally "further evaluation of remaining proposals to ensure selection of viable projects that provide cost -effective, reliable Offshore Wind Energy Generation with limited risk."
Pursuant to the Department of Public Utilities order approving the solicitation process, projects will be selected for negotiation by April 23, 2018, with contracts submitted for Department approval no later than July 31, 2018.
Labels:
83C,
BOEM,
DOER,
DPU,
legislature,
Massachusetts,
Ocean,
offshore,
procurement,
RFP,
solicitation,
transmission,
wind,
wind energy area
New England regional renewables procurement
Thursday, June 1, 2017
As states enact and pursue energy policy goals such as sourcing power from solar, offshore wind, or other "clean energy" resources, here's a quick look at some of the regional renewable procurement activity ongoing in New England:
New England Clean Energy RFP: This "three-State Clean Energy RFP" focused on Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Rhode Island. Although each state enacted its own statutory framework for procurement, soliciting parties including the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Policy and utilities in Massachusetts and Rhode Island released a joint Request for Proposals in September 2015. Bids were due by January 28, 2016. Following an evaluation period, bidders were selected for contract negotiation and notified on October 24, 2016. The states collectively selected the following proposals representing approximately 460 megawatts in total:
Massachusetts Section 83D RFP for Long-term Contracts for Clean Energy: On March 31, 2017, the Massachusetts Electric Distribution companies, in coordination with the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources, issued a Request for Proposals for Long-term Contracts for Clean Energy Projects pursuant to Section 83D of Chapter 169 of the Acts of 2008, as amended by chapter 188 of the Acts of 2016, An Act to Promote Energy Diversity. Bids are due by July 27, 2017, with project selection expected in January 2018.
New England Clean Energy RFP: This "three-State Clean Energy RFP" focused on Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Rhode Island. Although each state enacted its own statutory framework for procurement, soliciting parties including the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Policy and utilities in Massachusetts and Rhode Island released a joint Request for Proposals in September 2015. Bids were due by January 28, 2016. Following an evaluation period, bidders were selected for contract negotiation and notified on October 24, 2016. The states collectively selected the following proposals representing approximately 460 megawatts in total:
Massachusetts/Connecticut/RIMassachusetts Section 83C RFP for Long-term Contracts for Offshore Wind Energy: A 2016 state law requires utilities to competitively solicit and contract for approximately 1,600 megawatts of offshore wind, starting by June 30, 2017. On April 28, 2017, submitted their proposed RFP to the Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities for review and approval. Through the RFP, the utilities will seek proposals for “Offshore Wind Energy Generation” and associated transmission necessary to deliver such generation to the mainland ISO New England, Inc. grid. According to the proposed timeline, bids would be due in December 2017, with project selection in May 2018.
Antrim Wind
Ranger Solar
Cassadaga Wind
RES Americas – Both Submissions(1 and 2)
Massachusetts/RI
Deepwater Wind
Ameresco
Massachusetts Section 83D RFP for Long-term Contracts for Clean Energy: On March 31, 2017, the Massachusetts Electric Distribution companies, in coordination with the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources, issued a Request for Proposals for Long-term Contracts for Clean Energy Projects pursuant to Section 83D of Chapter 169 of the Acts of 2008, as amended by chapter 188 of the Acts of 2016, An Act to Promote Energy Diversity. Bids are due by July 27, 2017, with project selection expected in January 2018.
Labels:
Clean Energy,
ISONE,
offshore wind,
Renewable,
RFP,
solar,
solicitation,
transmission,
wind
Will clustering help New England's interconnection queue?
Tuesday, May 16, 2017
Faced with a persistent backlog of requests to interconnect to the electric grid across parts of New England, will the region's major grid operator adopt a "clustering" methodology to streamline the study process and reduce procedural delays?
At issue are ISO New England's interconnection procedures, which govern the process through which generators and transmission lines may interconnect to the New England bulk power system. For nearly all large projects and some smaller ones, ISO-NE administers the process and conducts extensive engineering studies to determine whether such interconnections would be feasible without adversely affecting reliability and how they should be accomplished. In general, ISO-NE uses a first-come, first-served basis: a project's impacts on the grid are studied in sequential order based on that project's position in the interconnection queue. In practice, this means that a project's studies do not commence until the studies for projects ahead in line are complete.
According to ISO-NE, this system has worked well for most of the region. Excluding northern and western Maine, the grid operator reports that on average, system impact studies are completed within a year of the customer's interconnection request. But ISO-NE notes that its "Interconnection Queue has experienced a persistent backlog of requests to interconnect in northern & western Maine." Many of these requests relate to wind projects located relatively far from the transmission system, but similar challenges could arise relating to large solar projects in parts of Maine, Vermont, or New Hampshire.
The grid operator may be able to address this backlog by changing its interconnection procedures to be more in line those adopted in other regions, by allowing "clustering" or pooled and simultaneous study of certain resources. As described by ISO-NE in a presentation delivered last year, all of the other Independent System Operators or Regional Transmission Organizations -- such as NYISO, PJM, MISO, CAISO, and SPP - include some form of clustering in the interconnection process; New England stakeholders have requested that ISO-NE investigate clustering; and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has also addressed clustering, including in a May 2016 technical conference.
ISO-NE's proposed clustering methodology would allow, under specific circumstances, for two or more Interconnection Requests to be analyzed in the same System Impact Study (SIS) effort. Projects participating in a cluster would share cost responsibility for certain shared interconnection related transmission upgrades, known as Cluster Enabling Transmission Upgrades (CETU), identified by ISO-NE as necessary for the applicable interconnection requests to interconnect.
As noted in an April 2017 presentation to the NEPOOL Participants Committee, this proposal was favorably voted by the Transmission Committee on January 24, 2017 and by the Participants Committee on February 3, 2017.
The presumptive next step forward in New England's attempt to resolve the interconnection queue backlog by clustering studies would be that ISO-NE will file its tariff revisions with the FERC -- but the grid operator has signaled an intent to wait to file the revisions until there is "a high probability of a FERC quorum." Three of the five seats on the Commission are presently vacant, and the Commission is currently operating without a quorum. In the meanwhile, ISO New England's present tariff does not allow clustering of studies, so for now customers and others proposing to interconnect generation or transmission into the New England grid will continue to wait and push for reform.
At issue are ISO New England's interconnection procedures, which govern the process through which generators and transmission lines may interconnect to the New England bulk power system. For nearly all large projects and some smaller ones, ISO-NE administers the process and conducts extensive engineering studies to determine whether such interconnections would be feasible without adversely affecting reliability and how they should be accomplished. In general, ISO-NE uses a first-come, first-served basis: a project's impacts on the grid are studied in sequential order based on that project's position in the interconnection queue. In practice, this means that a project's studies do not commence until the studies for projects ahead in line are complete.
According to ISO-NE, this system has worked well for most of the region. Excluding northern and western Maine, the grid operator reports that on average, system impact studies are completed within a year of the customer's interconnection request. But ISO-NE notes that its "Interconnection Queue has experienced a persistent backlog of requests to interconnect in northern & western Maine." Many of these requests relate to wind projects located relatively far from the transmission system, but similar challenges could arise relating to large solar projects in parts of Maine, Vermont, or New Hampshire.
The grid operator may be able to address this backlog by changing its interconnection procedures to be more in line those adopted in other regions, by allowing "clustering" or pooled and simultaneous study of certain resources. As described by ISO-NE in a presentation delivered last year, all of the other Independent System Operators or Regional Transmission Organizations -- such as NYISO, PJM, MISO, CAISO, and SPP - include some form of clustering in the interconnection process; New England stakeholders have requested that ISO-NE investigate clustering; and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has also addressed clustering, including in a May 2016 technical conference.
ISO-NE's proposed clustering methodology would allow, under specific circumstances, for two or more Interconnection Requests to be analyzed in the same System Impact Study (SIS) effort. Projects participating in a cluster would share cost responsibility for certain shared interconnection related transmission upgrades, known as Cluster Enabling Transmission Upgrades (CETU), identified by ISO-NE as necessary for the applicable interconnection requests to interconnect.
As noted in an April 2017 presentation to the NEPOOL Participants Committee, this proposal was favorably voted by the Transmission Committee on January 24, 2017 and by the Participants Committee on February 3, 2017.
The presumptive next step forward in New England's attempt to resolve the interconnection queue backlog by clustering studies would be that ISO-NE will file its tariff revisions with the FERC -- but the grid operator has signaled an intent to wait to file the revisions until there is "a high probability of a FERC quorum." Three of the five seats on the Commission are presently vacant, and the Commission is currently operating without a quorum. In the meanwhile, ISO New England's present tariff does not allow clustering of studies, so for now customers and others proposing to interconnect generation or transmission into the New England grid will continue to wait and push for reform.
Maine PUC releases 2015 renewable report
Wednesday, April 19, 2017
Maine energy regulators have released a report on the state's electricity renewable portfolio standard, presenting data from 2015. The Maine Public Utilities Commission's Annual Report on New Renewable Resource Portfolio Requirement - Report for 2015 Activity [PDF] provides a look at Maine's renewables law, now in its tenth year on the books. It may also inform legislative discussions later this spring about the future of Maine's renewable portfolio standard.
In 2007, the Maine legislature enacted a law requiring that specified percentages of electricity that supply Maine’s consumers come from “new” or Class 1 renewable resources, ranging from 1% in 2008 to 10% in 2017. The law also required the Commission to report annually to the legislative energy committee on the status of this requirement and related compliance matters.
According to the report, Maine suppliers sourced approximately 891,757 renewable energy certificates or RECs, from 30 facilities, to comply with the 2015 requirement. Of these, 20 facilities were fueled by biomass, 4 by hydropower, 3 by wind and 1 by landfill gas. 25 out of the 30 facilities were located in Maine, with 2 in New York, and one each in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Vermont. By REC volume, 99% came from facilities located in Maine.
The report also estimates the cost to Maine ratepayers of Maine's new renewable resource portfolio requirement. According to the report, the cost of RECs used for compliance in 2015 ranged from "approximately $2.00 per MWh to $42.50 per MWh, with an average cost of $13.16 per MWh and a total cost of $11,738,174." Adding in $3,018 in alternative compliance payments by one supplier, the report estimates a total cost to ratepayers during 2015 of $11,741,192. The report translates this total cost into "an average rate impact of about one-tenth of a cent per kWh. This is equivalent to about 55 cents per month, or 1%, for a typical residential customer; $50 per month for a medium commercial customer that uses 50,000 kWh per month; and $500 per month for a large commercial/industrial customer that uses 500,000 kWh per month."
Maine law also includes a Class 2 renewable portfolio standard, requiring an additional 30% of electricity come from existing renewables and other Class 2 resources. According to the Commission's report, the average cost of a Class 2 REC in 2015 was $0.28 per MWh, with a total cost of $965,818. The report notes that this is "equivalent to about 5 cents per month for a typical residential customer, and $4 and $40 per month for medium and large commercial/industrial customers with the usage levels described above, respectively."
This session, the 128th Maine Legislature is considering several bills that could affect Maine's renewable energy laws, including LD 532, An Act To Remove the 100-megawatt Limit on Hydroelectric Generators under the Renewable Resources Laws, as well as LD 1185, a concept draft which "proposes to enact measures designed to update Maine's renewable portfolio standards."
In 2007, the Maine legislature enacted a law requiring that specified percentages of electricity that supply Maine’s consumers come from “new” or Class 1 renewable resources, ranging from 1% in 2008 to 10% in 2017. The law also required the Commission to report annually to the legislative energy committee on the status of this requirement and related compliance matters.
According to the report, Maine suppliers sourced approximately 891,757 renewable energy certificates or RECs, from 30 facilities, to comply with the 2015 requirement. Of these, 20 facilities were fueled by biomass, 4 by hydropower, 3 by wind and 1 by landfill gas. 25 out of the 30 facilities were located in Maine, with 2 in New York, and one each in Connecticut, Massachusetts, and Vermont. By REC volume, 99% came from facilities located in Maine.
The report also estimates the cost to Maine ratepayers of Maine's new renewable resource portfolio requirement. According to the report, the cost of RECs used for compliance in 2015 ranged from "approximately $2.00 per MWh to $42.50 per MWh, with an average cost of $13.16 per MWh and a total cost of $11,738,174." Adding in $3,018 in alternative compliance payments by one supplier, the report estimates a total cost to ratepayers during 2015 of $11,741,192. The report translates this total cost into "an average rate impact of about one-tenth of a cent per kWh. This is equivalent to about 55 cents per month, or 1%, for a typical residential customer; $50 per month for a medium commercial customer that uses 50,000 kWh per month; and $500 per month for a large commercial/industrial customer that uses 500,000 kWh per month."
Maine law also includes a Class 2 renewable portfolio standard, requiring an additional 30% of electricity come from existing renewables and other Class 2 resources. According to the Commission's report, the average cost of a Class 2 REC in 2015 was $0.28 per MWh, with a total cost of $965,818. The report notes that this is "equivalent to about 5 cents per month for a typical residential customer, and $4 and $40 per month for medium and large commercial/industrial customers with the usage levels described above, respectively."
This session, the 128th Maine Legislature is considering several bills that could affect Maine's renewable energy laws, including LD 532, An Act To Remove the 100-megawatt Limit on Hydroelectric Generators under the Renewable Resources Laws, as well as LD 1185, a concept draft which "proposes to enact measures designed to update Maine's renewable portfolio standards."
Labels:
ACP,
biomass,
compliance,
Connecticut,
cost,
hydropower,
landfill gas,
Maine,
Massachusetts,
New York,
REC,
Renewable,
report,
RPS,
Vermont,
wind
US auctions North Carolina offshore wind sites
Friday, March 17, 2017
Yesterday the U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management completed a competitive lease sale for renewable wind energy development in federal waters offshore North Carolina. Avangrid Renewables, LLC won the auction-based sale with a high bid of $9,066,650. As a result, it has the right to lease 122,045 areas of ocean space in the designated Kitty Hawk Wind Energy Area.
The Kitty Hawk Wind Energy Area sits 24 nautical miles from shore, off the northeast coast of North Carolina by the Virginia border. The base roughly triangular area extends 25.7 nautical miles in a general southeast direction, with a seaward apex in the northeast. Using the National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s estimates of 3 megawatts per square kilometer, the lease area has a potential generating capacity of 1,486 megawatts.
BOEM announced the Kitty Hawk auction in January 2017. Its conclusion yesterday represents the first federal offshore wind lease sale under the Trump administration. According to BOEM, three other bidders particiated in the auction: Wind Future LLC, Statoil Wind US LLC, and wpd offshore Alpha LLC.
The North Carolina auction was BOEM's seventh competitive lease sale. In all, competitive lease sales have raised about $67 million for the federal government. While no commercial offshore wind projects are currently operating in federal waters, the Deepwater Wind Block Island project off Rhode Island began commercial operation last year.
The Kitty Hawk Wind Energy Area sits 24 nautical miles from shore, off the northeast coast of North Carolina by the Virginia border. The base roughly triangular area extends 25.7 nautical miles in a general southeast direction, with a seaward apex in the northeast. Using the National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s estimates of 3 megawatts per square kilometer, the lease area has a potential generating capacity of 1,486 megawatts.
BOEM announced the Kitty Hawk auction in January 2017. Its conclusion yesterday represents the first federal offshore wind lease sale under the Trump administration. According to BOEM, three other bidders particiated in the auction: Wind Future LLC, Statoil Wind US LLC, and wpd offshore Alpha LLC.
The North Carolina auction was BOEM's seventh competitive lease sale. In all, competitive lease sales have raised about $67 million for the federal government. While no commercial offshore wind projects are currently operating in federal waters, the Deepwater Wind Block Island project off Rhode Island began commercial operation last year.
Labels:
Kitty Hawk,
North Carolina,
offshore,
Virginia,
wind
NY offshore wind lease auction set
Monday, October 31, 2016
The U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management has issued a Final Sale Notice, setting December 15 as the date for auctioning the right to lease sites in federal waters off New York for commercial offshore wind development.
The U.S. federal government is pursuing a national strategy to facilitate the domestic development of offshore wind energy. Under federal law, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management is responsible for administering renewable energy project development on the offshore Outer Continental Shelf. The strategy calls for BOEM to identify areas suitable for wind energy leasing, and to then offer leases through auctions or other sales.
BOEM is now moving forward with plans to auction leasing rights for an area offshore New York. In June 2016, BOEM first issued a Proposed Sale Notice for leasing rights off New York. BOEM solicited public comment on its proposal over the summer.
On October 27, 2016, BOEM announced the designation of a final New York Wind Energy Area, starting approximately 11.5 nautical miles from Jones Beach, NY, and running approximately 24 nm southeast. The final New York Wind Energy Area differs from BOEM's earlier leasing proposal primarily in its removal of about 1,780 acres due to environmental concerns over sensitive habitat on a feature called Cholera Bank.
BOEM's announcement also identified 14 companies that it has deemed legally, technically and financially qualified to participate in the New York lease sale:
Meanwhile, state energy agency NYSERDA is pursuing the New York State Offshore Wind Master Plan to advance offshore wind development in the state. NYSERDA has expressed interest in bidding in a BOEM auction for project leasing rights, and was included in BOEM's list of entities qualified for the December 15 auction. Moreover, NYSERDA could be a beneficiary of the "government authority" provision in BOEM's Final Sale Notice; if so, it could receive a 10% credit on top of its cash bid.
BOEM will conduct the auction electronically, through a contractor, starting at 8:30 EST on December 15, 2016.
The U.S. federal government is pursuing a national strategy to facilitate the domestic development of offshore wind energy. Under federal law, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management is responsible for administering renewable energy project development on the offshore Outer Continental Shelf. The strategy calls for BOEM to identify areas suitable for wind energy leasing, and to then offer leases through auctions or other sales.
BOEM is now moving forward with plans to auction leasing rights for an area offshore New York. In June 2016, BOEM first issued a Proposed Sale Notice for leasing rights off New York. BOEM solicited public comment on its proposal over the summer.
On October 27, 2016, BOEM announced the designation of a final New York Wind Energy Area, starting approximately 11.5 nautical miles from Jones Beach, NY, and running approximately 24 nm southeast. The final New York Wind Energy Area differs from BOEM's earlier leasing proposal primarily in its removal of about 1,780 acres due to environmental concerns over sensitive habitat on a feature called Cholera Bank.
BOEM's announcement also identified 14 companies that it has deemed legally, technically and financially qualified to participate in the New York lease sale:
- Avangrid Renewables, LLC
- CI-II NY Inc.
- DONG Energy Wind Power (U.S.) Inc.
- Innogy US Renewable Projects LLC
- wpd offshore Alpha LLC
- Deepwater Wind Hudson Canyon, LLC
- Energy Management, Inc.
- Convalt Energy LLC
- Clean Power Northeast Development Inc.
- New York State Energy Research and Development Authority
- Statoil Wind US LLC
- EDF Renewable Development, Inc.
- Fishermen’s Energy, LLC
- Sea Breeze Energy LLC
Meanwhile, state energy agency NYSERDA is pursuing the New York State Offshore Wind Master Plan to advance offshore wind development in the state. NYSERDA has expressed interest in bidding in a BOEM auction for project leasing rights, and was included in BOEM's list of entities qualified for the December 15 auction. Moreover, NYSERDA could be a beneficiary of the "government authority" provision in BOEM's Final Sale Notice; if so, it could receive a 10% credit on top of its cash bid.
BOEM will conduct the auction electronically, through a contractor, starting at 8:30 EST on December 15, 2016.
FERC Order 827 and reactive power
Monday, June 20, 2016
Federal energy regulators have issued a final rule requiring all newly interconnecting non-synchronous generators to provide reactive power, which supports the reliability of the electric grid. The rule adopted by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in Order No. 827 primarily affects wind generators, who have previously been exempt, and some solar projects.
Reactive power -- and generators capable of supplying or consuming it -- play an important role in controlling system voltage for efficient and reliable operation of an alternating current transmission system. Previously, as a condition of interconnection under the FERC's pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Agreement and Small Generator Interconnection Agreement, most generators have been required “to maintain a composite power delivery at continuous rated power output at the Point of Interconnection at a power factor within the range of 0.95 leading to 0.95 lagging.”
But historically, the costs to design and build a wind generator that could provide this kind of reactive power were high. In recognition that requiring wind generators to provide reactive power could have created an obstacle to the development of wind generation, the Commission previously exempted wind generators from the general requirement to provide reactive power, absent a study finding that the provision of reactive power is necessary to ensure safety or reliability.
But in 2014, a FERC staff report found that the cost of providing reactive power no longer presents an obstacle to the development of wind generation. So-called Type III and Type IV inverter-based turbines now offer inherent reactive power capabilities. As described in Order No. 827, "The resulting decline in the cost to wind generators of providing reactive power renders the current absolute exemptions unjust, unreasonable, and unduly discriminatory and preferential." The Commission also noted that integrating increasing amounts of wind increases the potential that some systems will need more reactive power.
Acting under Section 206 of the Federal Power Act, on June 16, 2016, the Commission found "that wind generators should not have an exemption from the reactive power requirement which is unavailable to other generators." At the same time, the Commission recognized technical differences that would add costs if non-synchronous generators were required to provide reactive power at the Point of Interconnection -- and that these "added costs will ultimately be borne by customers, whether through reactive power payments in regions that compensate for reactive power capability, or through elevated prices for capacity or energy in regions that do not compensate for reactive power capability."
It thus adopted reactive power requirements for newly interconnecting non-synchronous generators, but let non-synchronous generators provide dynamic reactive power at the high-side of the generator substation, as opposed to the Point of Interconnection.
The Commission described its expectation that non-synchronous generators may meet the dynamic reactive power requirement by utilizing a combination of the inherent dynamic reactive power capability of the inverter, dynamic reactive power devices (e.g., Static VAR Compensators), and static reactive power devices (e.g., capacitors) to make up for losses.
The Final Rule will become effective 90 days after its publication in the Federal Register. Its requirements will apply to all newly interconnecting non-synchronous generators that have not yet executed a Facilities Study Agreement as of the rule's effective date.
Reactive power -- and generators capable of supplying or consuming it -- play an important role in controlling system voltage for efficient and reliable operation of an alternating current transmission system. Previously, as a condition of interconnection under the FERC's pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Agreement and Small Generator Interconnection Agreement, most generators have been required “to maintain a composite power delivery at continuous rated power output at the Point of Interconnection at a power factor within the range of 0.95 leading to 0.95 lagging.”
But historically, the costs to design and build a wind generator that could provide this kind of reactive power were high. In recognition that requiring wind generators to provide reactive power could have created an obstacle to the development of wind generation, the Commission previously exempted wind generators from the general requirement to provide reactive power, absent a study finding that the provision of reactive power is necessary to ensure safety or reliability.
But in 2014, a FERC staff report found that the cost of providing reactive power no longer presents an obstacle to the development of wind generation. So-called Type III and Type IV inverter-based turbines now offer inherent reactive power capabilities. As described in Order No. 827, "The resulting decline in the cost to wind generators of providing reactive power renders the current absolute exemptions unjust, unreasonable, and unduly discriminatory and preferential." The Commission also noted that integrating increasing amounts of wind increases the potential that some systems will need more reactive power.
Acting under Section 206 of the Federal Power Act, on June 16, 2016, the Commission found "that wind generators should not have an exemption from the reactive power requirement which is unavailable to other generators." At the same time, the Commission recognized technical differences that would add costs if non-synchronous generators were required to provide reactive power at the Point of Interconnection -- and that these "added costs will ultimately be borne by customers, whether through reactive power payments in regions that compensate for reactive power capability, or through elevated prices for capacity or energy in regions that do not compensate for reactive power capability."
It thus adopted reactive power requirements for newly interconnecting non-synchronous generators, but let non-synchronous generators provide dynamic reactive power at the high-side of the generator substation, as opposed to the Point of Interconnection.
The Commission described its expectation that non-synchronous generators may meet the dynamic reactive power requirement by utilizing a combination of the inherent dynamic reactive power capability of the inverter, dynamic reactive power devices (e.g., Static VAR Compensators), and static reactive power devices (e.g., capacitors) to make up for losses.
The Final Rule will become effective 90 days after its publication in the Federal Register. Its requirements will apply to all newly interconnecting non-synchronous generators that have not yet executed a Facilities Study Agreement as of the rule's effective date.
Labels:
827,
FERC,
integrating wind,
inverter,
non-synchronous,
reactive,
Renewable,
solar,
synchronous,
wind
FERC Summer 2016 energy market and reliability report
Friday, May 20, 2016
Federal energy regulatory staff have presented their 2016 Summer Seasonal Assessment to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. The "Summer 2016 Energy Market and Reliability Assessment" presents an summer outlook by FERC's Office of Electric Reliability and Office of Enforcement on electricity and natural gas markets and reliability issues.
Highlights include:
Highlights include:
- "low natural gas prices that have resulted from robust production and near record levels of natural gas in storage"
- electric system reserve margins are expected to be adequate this summer, though tighter in Texas
- total U.S. load forecast, when weather-adjusted, is essentially unchanged in recent years, largely due to little to no load growth in commercial and residential sectors
- the total generating capacity in the U.S. has decreased by approximately 2 percent since last summer, primarily due to coal retirements. According to the report, "The factors that prompted these closures include increased competition from natural gas, environmental regulations and an average fleet age that exceeded 50 years old."
- Over 18 gigawatts of new generating capacity will be installed nationwide through the summer, with a majority of these capacity additions coming from renewables such as wind and solar, plus the first new U.S. nuclear unit in over 20 years.
- Organized markets are attempting to manage the growing impacts of renewable generation.
- FERC staff expects natural gas fired generation to remain robust; natural gas fired generation has surpassed coal plant output since July 2015. Meanwhile coal stockpiles are growing due to a decrease in coal generation.
- Natural gas future prices have fallen since last year, though the Boston region's price drop is not significant. Basis swaps -- financial instruments that represent the natural gas price differential between a specific point and the Henry Hub -- for Boston are priced higher than last summer, "suggesting expectations for greater congestion due to above-normal temperatures and a reduction in capacity along the Algonquin pipeline because of planned maintenance to tie in the Algonquin Incremental Market (AIM) expansion project this summer."
Labels:
Boston,
coal,
FERC,
margin,
market,
natural gas,
pipeline,
reliability,
Renewable,
report,
reserve,
retirement,
solar,
Texas,
wind
Generator interconnection technical conference scheduled
Wednesday, April 6, 2016
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has scheduled a technical conference to generator interconnection issues,
including interconnection of energy storage.
The case has its origins in a 2015 petition to the Commission by the American Wind Energy Association, seeking a rulemaking to revise certain provisions of the Commission's pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Procedures (“GIP”) and pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Agreement (“GIA”).
AWEA is a national trade association representing a broad range of entities with a common interest in encouraging the expansion and facilitation of wind energy resources in the United States. Its members include wind energy facility developers, owners and operators, construction contractors, turbine manufacturers, component suppliers, financiers, researchers, utilities, marketers, customers, and their advocates.
In that petition, the trade group argued:
The Commission has now issued notice of a technical conference to be held on May 13. According to the notice:
The case has its origins in a 2015 petition to the Commission by the American Wind Energy Association, seeking a rulemaking to revise certain provisions of the Commission's pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Procedures (“GIP”) and pro forma Large Generator Interconnection Agreement (“GIA”).
AWEA is a national trade association representing a broad range of entities with a common interest in encouraging the expansion and facilitation of wind energy resources in the United States. Its members include wind energy facility developers, owners and operators, construction contractors, turbine manufacturers, component suppliers, financiers, researchers, utilities, marketers, customers, and their advocates.
In that petition, the trade group argued:
the time is ripe for the Commission to make certain regulatory and policy changes to interconnection procedures in order to remedy unduly discriminatory and unreasonable barriers to generator market access that inhibit the development of electric generation to meet the growing needs of electricity customers, and to facilitate the current dramatic transformation of the electric generation system (driven, in part, by Federal and State policies) in a timely, reliable and cost-effective manner.AWEA's petition called for a variety of reforms to the interconnection procedures and agreement, particularly aimed at improving "(a) certainty in the study/restudy process; (b) transparency in the interconnection process; (c) certainty of network upgrade costs; and (d) accountability in the interconnection process." After many comments were submitted on the rulemaking petition, AWEA asked the Commission to hold a technical conference as a forum for "open discussion" among interested parties.
The Commission has now issued notice of a technical conference to be held on May 13. According to the notice:
The purpose of this conference is to discuss select issues related to a petition for rulemaking submitted by the American Wind Energy Association (Docket No. RM15-21-000). In addition, the conference will explore other generator interconnection issues, including interconnection of energy storage.The notice also states that discussions at the conference may involve issues raised in other proceedings pending before the Commission, including without limitation 8 sets of specifically listed cases:
- E.ON Climate & Renewables North America LLC, Pioneer Trail Wind Farm, LLC, Settlers Trail Wind Farm, LLC v. Northern Indiana Public Service Company, Docket No. EL14-66-002;
- Entergy Arkansas, Inc., Docket No. ER14-671-000;
- Internal MISO Generators v. Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Docket No. EL15-99-000;
- Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Docket No. ER16-675-000;
- California Independent System Operator Corporation, Docket No. ER16-693-000;
- ISO New England, Inc., Docket No. ER16-946-000;
- Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Docket No. ER16-1120-000; and
The conference will be held on May 13 at Commission headquarters in Washington, DC.
- Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc., Docket No. ER16-1211-000.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

