Showing posts with label tariff. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tariff. Show all posts

NJ considers PJM capacity market alternatives

Monday, March 30, 2020

The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities has opened an investigation into "how the State can best achieve its reliability, clean energy, and environmental objectives, while keeping costs to consumers as low as possible." Like many states, New Jersey’s utilities participate in a federally regulated regional transmission organization’s capacity market, but are also subject to state clean energy laws -- a tension that has caused the state's energy regulators to consider whether to leave the PJM regional capacity market.

At issue is whether New Jersey can "achieve its long-term clean energy and environmental objectives under the current resource adequacy procurement paradigm" -- the regional electric capacity market operated by PJM Interconnection -- or whether it should adopt an alternative mechanism to "meet New Jersey’s resource adequacy needs in a manner consistent with the State’s clean energy and environmental objectives, while considering costs to utility customers."

New Jersey electric utilities currently participate in the PJM regional markets, including a capacity market. The state has adopted a 2019 Energy Master Plan: Pathway to 2050, establishing a series of state-focused clean energy goals such as 7,500 MW of offshore wind by 2035 and 100% clean energy by 2050. Other states in the PJM region have adopted different clean energy goals.

At the same time, PJM's regional market is federally regulated. In December 2019, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission directed PJM to modify its "Minimum Offer Price Rule" or MOPR, governing the capacity market. Designed to counteract excessive market power, the federal ruling directed PJM to modify its MOPR to also counteract the pricing effects of state clean energy policies. In its state Energy Master Plan, New Jersey described FERC's action as "actively attempting to support fossil fuel interests in the [PJM] region under the guise of promoting ‘fair’ competition."

In response to the FERC's MOPR order, on March 27, the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities issued an Order Initiating Proceeding in Docket No. EO20030203. Citing the federal order, the Board characterized it as "a direct attack on the State’s clean energy programs" and expressed concern that continued participation in the federally-regulated PJM market could frustrate New Jersey's ability to achieve its clean energy goals. The Board thus initiated a proceeding to consider whether to retain the current PJM market paradigm, or whether an alternative could achieve the state's climate and environmental goals at a lower cost to consumers.

Withdrawing from a regional transmission organization can be done under certain circumstances, but federally regulated tariffs and territories spanning multiple states with their own laws can complicate the path toward a clean break. As envisioned by the Board, possible alternatives for New Jersey might include using a "fixed resource requirement" or FRR approach under the PJM tariff to effectively withdraw one or more service areas from the broader PJM capacity market, or adopting a statewide clean energy standard that would require load-serving entities to source increased percentages of renewable or other clean energy.

Board staff subsequently issued a Request for Written Comments in the proceeding, soliciting written comments on four sets of topics by April 29. Issues raised in the request for comment include whether New Jersey could utilize the Fixed Resource Requirement alternative to satisfy its resource adequacy needs and accelerate its clean energy goals, whether modifications to the Board's Basic General Service construct could facilitate resource adequacy procurements aligned with the state's Energy Master Plan, and whether other mechanisms such as a clean energy standard or clean energy market could facilitate achievement of the state's clean energy goals.

Staff have suggested the Board's investigation will be completed later this year.

ISO-NE Pay for Performance starts June 2018

Tuesday, April 3, 2018

The operator of New England's electric grid and wholesale electricity markets has adopted a new design for its capacity market, called “Pay For Performance” or PFP, which will become effective on June 1, 2018. As of that date, capacity payments will reward power resources that make investments to successfully boost performance during periods of system stress, while resources that don’t perform will forfeit capacity payments. According to grid operator ISO New England, Inc., these capacity market reforms represent “a significant evolution of the Forward Capacity Market.”

Since 2008, ISO-NE has operated a wholesale market for electric capacity, in addition to markets for energy and ancillary services. According to the grid operator, its Forward Capacity Market (FCM) ensures that the New England power system will have sufficient resources to meet the future demand for electricity. The market design features annual Forward Capacity Auctions held three years in advance of the operating period, in which resources compete to obtain a commitment to supply capacity in exchange for a market-priced capacity payment.

ISO-NE first proposed a version of PFP in 2014 as a means to address what it characterized as "capacity resource performance issues in New England." According to an article by ISO-NE's chief executive officer, ISO-NE felt that the prevailing capacity market design increasingly failed to incentivize resource performance during times of system stress. The grid operator reported "escalating incidents of poor generator performance that have threatened bulk power system reliability," and identified a "broken linkage" between capacity payments and actual performance under the previous rules.

According to ISO-NE, its Pay for Performance reform "firmly connects capacity payments to resource performance." It is designed to increase financial incentives for resource owners to make investments to ensure their resource’s reliability during periods of scarcity.

The Pay for Performance market design is based on a “two-settlement approach” such as is used in forward markets for electricity and other commodities.

In a first stage, a market participant takes on a Capacity Supply Obligation – a forward obligation to provide a specified amount of capacity from its resource – in exchange for a Capacity Base Payment. That base payment is determined by multiplying the resource’s Capacity Supply Obligation (in megawatts) by the relevant clearing price – either the clearing price from a Forward Capacity Auction or reconfiguration auction, or a bilateral contract price. Once a market participant has taken on a Capacity Supply Obligation in exchange for the Capacity Base Payment, the participant has a physical, resource-specific obligation to cover a share of the system’s energy and reserve requirements during reserve deficiencies.

In a second stage, the participant is subject to a settlement for deviations from its committed share. Under PFP, this second payment, which can be positive or negative, is called the Capacity Performance Payment. If a resource delivers more than its share of the system’s requirements during a capacity scarcity condition, it will be paid an additional amount for that incremental production; if it delivers less than its share, it must “buy out” of its position by paying other resources that did deliver.

Tariff revisions were accepted by the FERC in 2014 and 2015, and ISO-NE has subsequently developed further changes to its tariff to implement the program. The revised tariff is scheduled to take effect on June 1, 2018.

FERC acts on 2017 tax cuts

Monday, March 19, 2018

Federal utility regulators have taken a portfolio of actions in response to recent changes to U.S. tax law which reduced the tax rates applicable to many electric utilities and pipeline companies. Some rates for use of infrastructure will be reduced automatically, while regulators prompted others to explain why they should not be reduced to reflect the tax law changes. At the same time, regulators have opened an inquiry and proposed a rulemaking to address further aspects of the 2017 federal tax law change.

Late last year, Congress enacted the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. That law amended U.S. tax law in a variety of ways. Among other things, the 2017 tax law changes reduced the federal corporate income tax rate from a maximum 35 percent to a flat 21 percent rate, effective January 1, 2018.

Many electric utilities and natural gas and oil pipeline companies stand to benefit from this tax reduction in the form of reduced income tax expense going forward, as well as a reduction in accumulated deferred income taxes on the books of rate-regulated companies. Where tax expense decreases, so does the cost of service.

Rates for use of some federally regulated energy infrastructure are set based on cost of service. On March 15, 2018, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission took a series of actions to address the effect of the tax law changes on its regulated industries including electric transmission companies, interstate natural gas pipelines, and oil pipelines. According to the Commission, its actions “recognize the specific regulatory and operating parameters that must be addressed differently for each of the industries it regulates.”

Transmission rates for most FERC-regulated utilities automatically adjust with changes in the tax rates based on a formula whose inputs are updated annually or on some other regular cycle. For these utilities, a reduction in corporate income tax means a reduction in rates, although the ratemaking process means there can be a lag in time before rate reductions take effect.

But in some cases, utility tariffs provide for rates are either stated as a fixed number, or the formula includes a fixed tax rate. The Commission identified 48 companies whose transmission tariffs specifically reference tax rates of 35 percent. In a pair of show-cause orders issued under the Federal Power Act -- one for utilities with stated rates, and one for utilities with formula rates referencing 35 percent -- the Commission directed these companies to propose revisions to their transmission rates or show why they should not do so. It also issued two waivers allowing certain utilities mid-year rate adjustments to reflect the new tax law.

Interstate natural gas pipelines typically have stated rates for their services. These rates are approved by the Commission in a rate proceeding under Natural Gas Act sections 4 or 5 and remain in effect until changed in a subsequent section 4 or 5 proceeding. To revise its practices with respect to natural gas pipelines, the Commission issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that would allow it determine which pipelines under the Natural Gas Act may be collecting unjust and unreasonable rates in light of the corporate tax reduction and the Commission’s recently revised policies on income tax allowance. Under the rule proposed by the Commission, interstate pipelines would need to file a one-time report called “FERC Form No. 501-G” describing the rate effect of these changes. In addition to filing the one-time report, each pipeline would have four options: a pro rata rate reduction, a rate settlement or case, an explanation why no rate change is needed, or merely filing the FERC report and letting the Commission decide if further action is required.

While cost-of-service ratemaking typically applies to public utilities and interstate natural gas pipelines, most oil pipelines set their rates using indexing. With respect to oil pipelines regulated by the FERC, the Commission said it will address tax changes in the 2020 five-year review of the oil pipeline index level.

Concurrently, the Commission opened an inquiry into the effect of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 on all jurisdictional rates, including whether the Commission should address certain changes relating to accumulated deferred income taxes and bonus depreciation. In a presentation to the Commission, staff described this Notice of Inquiry as "a vehicle to help the Commission build a record to determine whether additional action is needed."

In a separate policy statement and order issued on March 15, the Commission revised its policies to disallow income tax allowance cost recovery in MLP pipeline rates.

FERC ends DOE resilience rulemaking, opens new proceeding

Tuesday, January 9, 2018

U.S. energy regulators have terminated a fast-tracked proceeding opened last fall to consider rules proposed by the Department of Energy that would have compensated certain electric generating plants for reliability and resilience values; instead, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has opened a broader case to examine the resilience of the bulk power system.

On September 29, 2017, Secretary of Energy Rick Perry directed the Commission to consider a proposed rulemaking to ensure that "traditional baseload resources, such as coal and nuclear" are rewarded for their reliability and resilience attributes. As proposed, the rule would have required grid operators to set rates for compensation paid to certain "grid reliability and resiliency resources" with a 90-day fuel supply on site and capable of providing "essential energy and ancillary reliability services, including but not limited to voltage support, frequency services, operating reserves, and reactive power."

The request under Section 403 of the Department of Energy Organization Act bore an expedited timeline. The Commission solicited public comments on the proposed rulemaking, and Commission staff issued a series of questions to frame the discussion. Many comments expressed concerns that rapid changes to wholesale markets could have harmful or perverse effects, and prior to yesterday's most seated Commissioners had publicly expressed reservations.

On January 8, 2018, the Commission issued its Order Terminating Rulemaking Proceeding, Initiating New Proceeding, and Establishing Additional Procedures.  In doing so, it recognized "that we must remain vigilant with respect to resilience challenges, because affordable and reliable electricity is vital to the country’s economic and national security." The order recites a history of the evolution of the electric power industry and the Commission's efforts to help ensure bulk power system resilience, including the adoption of NERC reliability standards, reforms to capacity markets and gas-electric coordination.

But the Commission found that neither the Department of Energy's proposed rulemaking nor the record in the case satisfied a key legal standard for Commission action under Section 206 of the Federal Power Act. Specifically, it concluded that the existing tariffs had not been demonstrated to be unjust, unreasonable, unduly discriminatory or preferential.

The Commission also noted potential problems with the proposed rule. For example, it said that allowing all eligible resources to receive a cost-of -service rate regardless of need or cost to the system had not been demonstrated to be just and reasonable, and that the proposed rule's on-site 90-day fuel supply requirement hadn't been shown not to be unduly discriminatory or preferential -- but that it would exclude some resources with resilience attributes.

At the same time, the order states, "The resilience of the bulk power system will remain a priority of this Commission." It continued, "Although the Proposed Rule failed to satisfy the fundamental legal requirements of section 206 of the FPA, the Proposed Rule and the record developed to date have shed additional light on resilience more generally and on the need for further examination by the Commission and market participants of the risks that the bulk power system faces and possible ways to address those risks in the changing electric markets." Noting "a variety of economic, environmental, and policy drivers that are changing the way electricity is procured and used," the Commission said these changes "present new opportunities and challenges regarding the reliability, affordability, and environmental profile of each region’s electric system."

To address these changes, the Commission initiated a new proceeding, Docket No. AD18- 7-000, to take additional steps to explore resilience issues in organized wholesale electricity markets. According to the order, the goal of this proceeding is: "(1) to develop a common understanding among the Commission, industry, and others of what resilience of the bulk power system means and requires; (2) to understand how each RTO and ISO assesses resilience in its geographic footprint; and (3) to use this information to evaluate whether additional Commission action regarding resilience is appropriate at this time."

The Commission directed six regional transmission organizations and independent system operators to respond within 60 days with comments on the definition of resilience, plus how they assess and mitigate threats to resilience. The Commission also solicited public comment within 30 days of the grid operators' due date.

FERC grid reliability and resilience pricing questions

Tuesday, October 10, 2017

U.S. energy regulators have asked for public comment on a rule proposed by the Secretary of Energy that would require organized grid operators to pay certain electric generators for their grid reliability and resilience benefits.

On September 28, 2017, Secretary of Energy Rick Perry directed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to consider a proposed rule on an expedited basis.  The proposed rule defines an "eligible grid reliability and resiliency resource" based on criteria including the ability to provide essential energy and ancillary reliability services and to have a 90-day fuel supply on site enabling it to operate during an emergency, extreme weather conditions, or a natural or man-made disaster.  It would requires independent system operators and regional transmission organizations to establish a tariff that provides a " just and reasonable rate" for the purchase of electric energy from such resources including recovery of costs and a return on equity

On October 2, the Commission issued a Notice Inviting Comments, asking interested persons to submit comments regarding the proposal on or before October 23, 2017.  Two days later, Commission staff followed up with a series of questions for public comment.  Questions in that document cover topics including the need for reform, eligibility, implementation, and rates, as well as impacts on consumers.

Some questions posed by the Commission staff in its October 4, 2017 document are general, such as, "What is resilience, how is it measured, and how is it different from reliability? What levels of resilience and reliability are appropriate?"  Others ask for whether commenters agree with references in the proposed rule to the 2014 "Polar Vortex" and "other extreme weather events, specifically hurricanes Irma, Harvey, Maria, and superstorm Sandy," as well as "the retirement of coal and nuclear resources and a concern from Congress about the potential further loss of valuable generation resources" as justifying the need for action.

As previously noticed by the Commission, initial comments on the proposed Grid Reliability and Resilience Pricing Rule in Docket No. RM18-1-000 are due on or before October 23, 2017 and reply comments due on or before November 7, 2017.

FERC invites comment on grid reliability and resilience pricing proposal

Thursday, October 5, 2017

U.S. electricity regulators have invited public comment on a draft rule proposed by the Secretary of Energy that would require some grid operators to buy electricity from certain generators at rates that allow the generators to recover their costs and a return on equity.  The Secretary has set the grid resiliency pricing rulemaking proceeding on a fast track -- but some energy industry associations have asked regulators to allow more time for public participation before finalizing "a proposed rule that could affect electricity prices paid by hundreds of millions of consumers and hundreds of thousands of businesses, as well as entire industries and their tens of thousands of workers."

On September 28, Secretary Perry directed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to open an expedited rulemaking proceeding to consider a proposed rule affecting the compensation paid to certain "grid reliability and resiliency resources" with a 90-day fuel supply on site and capable of providing "essential energy and ancillary reliability services, including but not limited to voltage support, frequency services, operating reserves, and reactive power."

Acting under Section 403 of the Department of Energy Organization Act, Secretary Perry directed the Commission to consider and complete final action on his proposed rule proposed within 60 days.  But he also suggested that circumstances warrant faster action -- such as issuing the proposed rule as an interim final rule, effective immediately, with provision for later modifications after consideration of public comments.
 
On October 2, the Commission issued a Notice Inviting Comments in Docket No. RM18-1-000.  That notice invited interested persons to submit comments regarding the proposal on or before October 23, 2017, with reply comments due on or before November 7, 2017.

Also on October 2, a coalition of energy industry associations filed a joint motion asking the Commission to take more time in its consideration of the proposed grid resiliency pricing proposed rule or "NOPR".  In that joint motion, the associations note that no emergency or other circumstance exists which justifies the use of an interim final rule.  They cite the "importance and potential implications of the NOPR for Commission-jurisdictional markets," calling it "one of the most significant proposed rules in decades related to the energy industry."  The associations argue that because the time limits set by the Secretary are "unreasonable," so the Commission should set its own timeline allowing more time for participation.

The energy industry associations who filed the joint motion represent a fairly broad slice of the energy sector.  Participating associations include Advanced Energy Economy, American Council on Renewable Energy, American Petroleum Institute, American Wind Energy Association, American Public Power Association, Electric Power Supply Association, Electricity Consumers Resource Council, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America, National Rural Electric Cooperative Association, Natural Gas Supply Association, and Solar Energy Industries Association.

The grid resiliency pricing rule proceeding continues before the Commission.

Massachusetts next generation solar incentive

Friday, October 28, 2016

The Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources is developing a new solar incentive program.  DOER released its proposal for the next generation of solar incentives on September 23, 2016. 

The 2016 legislation, An Act Relative to Solar Energy, included an extension and expansion of net metering, a policy which has supported the development of most solar projects in Massachusetts to date.  But because the state's solar renewable energy certificate (SREC) program is reaching its end, the recent law also directed the Department to "develop a statewide solar incentive program to encourage the continued development of solar renewable energy generating sources by residential, commercial, governmental and industrial electricity customers."

The 2016 law specified certain required characteristics of the "next generation" solar incentive program, including that it must be one which: "promotes the orderly transition to a stable and self-sustaining solar market at a reasonable cost to ratepayers," considers underlying system costs, takes into account electricity revenues and incentives, relies on market-based mechanisms or price signals, minimizes costs and barriers, features a declining incentive framework, differentiates incentive levels, "ensures that the utility customer realizes the direct benefits of the solar incentive program," considers the value of distributed generation and encourages solar generation where it benefits the distribution system, shares program costs collectively among all ratepayers, and promotes investor confidence through long-term incentive revenue certainty and market stability.

DOER released its "Next Generation Incentive Straw Proposal" on September 23.  Highlights include:

  • DOER believes that a tariff-based incentive program would be best mechanism to continue supporting solar at the lowest cost to ratepayers.
  • Incentive values would be based primarily on project size, with "adders" for different types of project (based on location, off-taker, or policy considerations like promoting energy storage).
  • Project eligibility criteria include being connected to the electric grid in Massachusetts, interconnected on or after January 1, 2017, and not being qualified under the previous SREC I or SREC II programs.
  • Siting criteria are included - for example, ground mounted projects would be prohibited if sited in certain wetlands, prime farmlands or forest land, or permanently protected open space.
  • Changes to "solar canopy" policy, to allow solar canopies to be installed on agricultural land and over canals.
  • Additional support for solar facilities serving low-income properties.
DOER noted that implementing this vision would require rulemaking by DOER, as well as a proceeding before the Department of Public Utilities regarding tariffs.

DOER is accepting written comments on the proposed program design until October 28, 2016.

NH net metering bills passed

Thursday, March 17, 2016

The New Hampshire legislature is acting to expand that state's net metering programs.  Now the question is how much: a 50% expansion, or a doubling?

New Hampshire law requires electric distribution utilities to offer eligible customer-generators a standard tariff for net energy metering. Solar panels are the most commonly net metered type of generation, but other technologies are also used.  Net metering under these tariffs is available "on a first-come, first-served basis within each electric utility service area" until each utility hits its specific cap on net metered capacity.  Under existing law, each utility's cap is effectively its share of a statewide program cap of 50 megawatts.

On January 20, 2016, utility Eversource announced it had reached its cap, and that it would place new projects going forward on a wait list.  But New Hampshire is home to significant interest in expanding net metering.  In the same announcement, Eversource described its work with the state legislature "to enact an expansion to the net metering program."  As the utility said, "Such an expansion would alleviate much of the uncertainty being faced by customers and developers, and would provide time for stakeholders to investigate all of the various costs and benefits of distributed generation and to provide for a sustainable evolution of the net metering program."

Meanwhile, Eversource also indicated a request that state regulators "develop a more permanent solution to the challenge of fairly compensating developers of new distributed generation in a manner that does not shift costs to other customers."

In February, the New Hampshire Senate voted to increase the net metering cap from 50 megawatts to 75 megawatts.  That bill, S.B.333, also directed the New Hampshire Public Utilities Commission to develop a net metering tariff for all generation above the 75 megawatt cap.

This month the New Hampshire House passed H.B.1116, a bill that would double the cap, to 100 megawatts.

Under New Hampshire legislative process, these two bills must be reconciled before a proposal can be sent to Governor Maggie Hassan.  But she has expressed strong support for reconciling the bills and expanding net metering:
Lifting the cap on net metering is essential to the continued success of New Hampshire’s solar industry, and I applaud the House for its bipartisan vote to pass this critical measure. The Senate has already supported this legislation, and I urge them to concur with the version passed by the House and send this bill to my desk as quickly as possible so that we can lift the cap on net metering.
The New Hampshire House and Senate now have the opportunity to reconcile the bills and present them to Governor Hassan for her signature.  Assuming this happens, New Hampshire will significantly expand its net metering program in the near term.

MA solar policy faces change

Tuesday, March 1, 2016

Massachusetts solar energy faces uncertainty, as the two state policies most supportive of solar photovoltaic project development -- a solar project's right to produce solar renewable energy certificates and a customer's right to net meter -- reach their end.  With the Massachusetts SREC II and net metering programs ending, new solar energy projects face diminished and uncertain financial incentives.

Massachusetts has made a strong commitment to solar energy.  The Commonwealth met its original goal of 250 megawatts of solar power installations four years early, then set a new goal was set of 1,600 MW by 2020. As of May 2015, over 841 megawatts of solar capacity had been installed in Massachusetts.

As the Solar Energy Industries Association has noted, "The Massachusetts market is driven by net metering, a renewable portfolio standard with a solar goal along with an accompanying SREC market."  The Massachusetts Clean Energy Center seemingly agrees, listing net metering and SRECs as two key "production-based incentives and benefits" for solar system owners.
The Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources ran its Solar Carve-Out II, or SREC II, program from April 25, 2014 to February 5, 2016.  The DOER described the program as designed to support the market until 1,600 megawatts of photovoltaic capacity has been installed statewide.

But that limit has been reached, counting the 653.8 megawatts of PV capacity installed under the Department's SREC I program (which ran from 2010-2014), additional capacity installed under SREC II, and over 600 megawatts of additional projects having reservations filed for the remaining SREC II program capacity.  The practical effect is that new projects will not likely be able to participate in the SREC II program.  This removes a key incentive for Massachusetts solar development.

The other Massachusetts solar promotional program reaching its limit is the Commonwealth's net metering program.  Under net metering, customers of certain electric distribution companies who generate their own electricity may offset their electricity usage.  Effectively, the retail meter spins forward when the customer uses electricity from the utility grid, and it spins backward when the customer generates excess electricity.

Massachusetts law requires each distribution company to maintain net metering caps equal to 4% of the company’s highest historical peak load for private net metering customers, and another 5% for municipal or public entities.  Once an electric distribution company fills its net metering caps, it can no longer allow customers to take service under its net metering tariff.  National Grid has reached its cap in its service territory, with other service territories close to full.  If net metering is not available to Massachusetts customers, it will remove another incentive that has supported significant growth in the state's solar sector in recent years.

In 2015, several pieces of legislation were proposed to lift the net metering caps, but no bill respecting net metering passed both the House and Senate.  The House measure contained provisions including a shift from retail rate compensation for net metering to a wholesale rate for most systems after the 1,600 megawatt target is met, authority for utilities to impose a minimum bill charge on net metering customers after the target is reached, and increased opportunity for utility ownership of solar.  A 2014 effort to lift net metering caps and reform solar policy similarly died.

But with significant interest in solar, from citizens and communities to the Commonwealth, U.S., and even the United Nations following the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement, how will Massachusetts react to the end of its SREC II and net metering programs?  Will a third effort to increase net metering work?  What will the Department of Energy Resources offer as a successor to the Solar Carve-out II SREC program?