The New Jersey Board of Public Utilities has opened an investigation into "how the State can best achieve its reliability, clean energy, and environmental objectives, while keeping costs to consumers as low as possible." Like many states, New Jersey’s utilities participate in a
federally regulated regional transmission organization’s capacity
market, but are also subject to state clean energy laws -- a tension
that has caused the state's energy regulators to consider whether to
leave the PJM regional capacity market.
At issue is whether New Jersey can "achieve its long-term clean energy and environmental objectives under the current resource adequacy procurement paradigm" -- the regional electric capacity market operated by PJM Interconnection -- or whether it should adopt an alternative mechanism to "meet New Jersey’s resource adequacy needs in a manner consistent with
the State’s clean energy and environmental objectives, while considering
costs to utility customers."
New Jersey electric utilities currently participate in the PJM regional markets, including a capacity market. The state has adopted a 2019 Energy Master Plan: Pathway to 2050, establishing a series of state-focused clean energy goals such as 7,500 MW of offshore wind by 2035 and 100% clean energy by 2050. Other states in the PJM region have adopted different clean energy goals.
At the same time, PJM's regional market is federally regulated. In December 2019, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission directed PJM to modify its "Minimum Offer Price Rule" or MOPR, governing the capacity
market. Designed to counteract excessive market power, the federal ruling directed PJM to modify its MOPR to also counteract the pricing effects of state clean energy
policies. In its state Energy Master Plan, New Jersey described FERC's action as "actively attempting to support fossil fuel interests in the [PJM] region under the guise of promoting ‘fair’ competition."
In response to the FERC's MOPR order, on March 27, the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities issued an Order Initiating Proceeding in Docket No. EO20030203. Citing the federal order, the Board characterized it as "a direct attack on the State’s clean energy programs" and expressed concern that continued participation in the federally-regulated PJM market could frustrate New Jersey's ability to achieve its clean energy goals. The Board thus initiated a proceeding to consider whether to retain the current PJM market paradigm, or whether an alternative could achieve the state's climate and environmental goals at a lower cost to consumers.
Withdrawing from a regional transmission organization can be done under certain circumstances, but federally regulated tariffs and territories spanning multiple states with their own laws can complicate the path toward a clean break. As envisioned by the Board, possible alternatives for New Jersey might include using a "fixed resource requirement" or FRR approach under the PJM tariff to effectively withdraw one or more service areas from the broader PJM capacity market, or adopting a statewide clean energy standard that would require load-serving entities to source increased percentages of renewable or other clean energy.
Board staff subsequently issued a Request for Written Comments in the proceeding, soliciting written comments on four sets of topics by April 29. Issues raised in the request for comment include whether New Jersey could utilize the Fixed Resource Requirement alternative to satisfy its resource adequacy needs and accelerate its clean energy goals, whether modifications to the Board's Basic General Service construct could facilitate resource adequacy procurements aligned with the state's Energy Master Plan, and whether other mechanisms such as a clean energy standard or clean energy market could facilitate achievement of the state's clean energy goals.
Staff have suggested the Board's investigation will be completed later this year.
Showing posts with label withdrawal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label withdrawal. Show all posts
NJ considers PJM capacity market alternatives
Monday, March 30, 2020
Labels:
capacity,
FERC,
Fixed Resource Requirement,
FRR,
market rule,
MOPR,
New Jersey,
NJ,
PJM,
tariff,
withdrawal
May 26, 2011 - NJ to withdraw from greenhouse gas compact
Thursday, May 26, 2011
New Jersey Governor Chris Christie has announced that he will pull New Jersey out of the nation's leading regional greenhouse gas cap-and-trade program.
Since 2007, New Jersey has participated in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. RGGI is the first market-based greenhouse gas regulatory program in the United States. RGGI represents a cooperative effort by Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island and Vermont. These ten states agreed to cap and reduce their electrical energy sector's greenhouse gas emissions by 10% by 2018.
While each state's legislature implemented its own version of the compact, the overall structure is that carbon allowances are auctioned off to the power sector. Proceeds from these auctions are invested in energy efficiency, renewable energy, and other clean energy technologies. The program has been a success in creating jobs, reducing greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector, and funding high-yield energy efficiency projects at businesses.
If New Jersey withdraws from RGGI, it will be the first state to end its participation in the program. Other states are considering whether to stay in the compact. For example, New Hampshire recently considered the question, and the Maine Legislature's energy committee recently voted to support a bill to withdraw from RGGI if enough other states withdraw first. Under LD 793 as amended, Maine would withdraw from RGGI if the total carbon dioxide emissions budget for remaining states is less than 35,000,000 tons. While New Jersey's departure alone would not shrink the program below Maine's proposed threshold, it would represent the first concrete erosion of RGGI's base.
![]() |
| The Maine State House, seen on a recent day of legislative debate over energy policy. |
Since 2007, New Jersey has participated in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. RGGI is the first market-based greenhouse gas regulatory program in the United States. RGGI represents a cooperative effort by Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island and Vermont. These ten states agreed to cap and reduce their electrical energy sector's greenhouse gas emissions by 10% by 2018.
While each state's legislature implemented its own version of the compact, the overall structure is that carbon allowances are auctioned off to the power sector. Proceeds from these auctions are invested in energy efficiency, renewable energy, and other clean energy technologies. The program has been a success in creating jobs, reducing greenhouse gas emissions from the power sector, and funding high-yield energy efficiency projects at businesses.
If New Jersey withdraws from RGGI, it will be the first state to end its participation in the program. Other states are considering whether to stay in the compact. For example, New Hampshire recently considered the question, and the Maine Legislature's energy committee recently voted to support a bill to withdraw from RGGI if enough other states withdraw first. Under LD 793 as amended, Maine would withdraw from RGGI if the total carbon dioxide emissions budget for remaining states is less than 35,000,000 tons. While New Jersey's departure alone would not shrink the program below Maine's proposed threshold, it would represent the first concrete erosion of RGGI's base.
Labels:
793,
energy efficiency,
funding,
greenhouse gas,
Maine,
New Hampshire,
New Jersey,
NH,
RGGI,
withdrawal
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

