NECA Fuels Conference 2018

Northeast Energy and Commerce Association holds its 2018 Fuels Conference on September 27, 2018, in Marlborough, Massachusetts.

NECA is New England's oldest and most broadly-based, non-profit trade association serving the competitive electric power industry.

The program for NECA's 2018 Fuels Conference features diverse perspectives on fuels including natural gas (pipeline and LNG), biogas, oil, and other fuels, and in their uses such as electric power generation, heating, and transportation. Speakers will share their outlook for U.S. and New England natural gas markets, address the trend towards electrification of sectors like heating and transportation, explain the portfolio of fuels used to heat and power the region, and discuss what consumers can expect from lawmakers, regulators, and energy providers.

Registration is available through NECA's website.

Wind to power Microsoft's Texas data center

Microsoft has agreed to purchase energy produced by a Texas wind farm to power its data center in San Antonio.  The announcement, posted on the official blog of Microsoft's Sustainability Development Team, describes a 20-year power purchase agreement with RES Americas under which Microsoft will purchase all of the output of the 110 megawatt Keechi Wind project located about 280 miles north.

The power purchase agreement fits with Microsoft's stated commitment to carbon neutrality.  Since 2012, Microsoft has imposed an internal fee on the use of carbon-based forms of energy; Microsoft uses that fee to make investments in alternative or carbon-neutral energy, such as this power purchase agreement.

The Keechi project will be owned and operated by RES Americas, a subsidiary of British company RES Ltd.  RES Americas currently operates over 600 MW of renewable energy projects, and has a renewable energy construction portfolio that exceeds 6,500 MW and 64 projects, as well as 534 miles of transmission lines.  Its Keechi project is expected to cost $200 million, and will feature 55 turbines expected to produce 430,000 megawatt hours of energy per year.  (To put this figure in context, it could power up to 45,000 homes, or cover between 5 and 10 percent of Microsoft's total electricity consumption.)  Construction is expected to begin in 2014, with the project going operational by June 2015.

Microsoft is not alone in promoting its use of renewable or alternative energy to power its data centers.  In 2012 Google entered into an agreement to purchase the output of a wind farm in Oklahoma to power its Pryor data center.  Apple's new data center in Maiden, North Carolina is powered in part by a solar photovoltaic array and a biogas-fed fuel cell.  eBay has proposed siting a 6 megawatt natural gas-fired fuel cell at its Utah data center.  Whether the data center is powered by on-site distributed generation or buys power from a designated off-site renewable resource, the trend is toward promoting cleaner, greener computing through these arrangements.  These choices may help the companies with cost control and power reliability as well as public relations.

Will large consumers of electricity continue to invest in alternative or renewable electric generation?  If so, will they favor arms-length power purchase agreements with developers of remote projects, or will they rely more heavily on on-campus development of distributed generation?  Will this trend spread beyond the big names so far - Microsoft, Apple, Google, and eBay - to the point where smaller or less tech-oriented companies develop or do similar projects and deals?

  Googa 20-year power purchase agreement (PPA) for wind energy in Texas that will be funded in part by proceeds from Microsoft’s carbon fee - See more at: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/microsoft-green/archive/2013/11/04/microsoft-signing-long-term-deal-to-buy-wind-energy-in-texas.aspx#sthash.4l62oNbo.dpuf

a 20-year power purchase agreement (PPA) for wind energy in Texas that will be funded in part by proceeds from Microsoft’s carbon fee - See more at: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/microsoft-green/archive/2013/11/04/microsoft-signing-long-term-deal-to-buy-wind-energy-in-texas.aspx#sthash.4l62oNbo.dpuf

a 20-year power purchase agreement (PPA) for wind energy in Texas that will be funded in part by proceeds from Microsoft’s carbon fee - See more at: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/microsoft-green/archive/2013/11/04/microsoft-signing-long-term-deal-to-buy-wind-energy-in-texas.aspx#sthash.4l62oNbo.dpuf

FERC report shows investment in natural gas

This week the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission issued its monthly energy infrastructure update covering May 2013.  The report details highlights in expansions of energy assets, ranging from natural gas pipelines to electric generation and transmission facilities.  It provides a monthly snapshot of recent activity, and can be used to spot trends in domestic energy development.  The current report illustrates increased investment in natural gas-related infrastructure, ranging from proposed new liquefied natural gas export terminals to newly installed natural gas-fired power plants.

The iconic U.S Capitol dome, where policies are made that shape energy investment.

Natural gas exports poised for growth.  Last month two facilities to liquefy natural gas for export advanced through the FERC regulatory process:

• Jordan Cove Energy requested authorization to construct and operate four liquefaction trains and storage facilities at a proposed export terminal in Coos Bay, Oregon.  If authorized and built, the project could export up to 900 MMcf per day of liquefied natural gas (LNG).  This gas would likely be destined for Asian markets.
• Golden Pass Products proposed a larger project in Texas.  Along with Golden Pass Pipeline, Golden Pass Products commenced the FERC prefiling process to construct and operate a 2,100 MMcf per day liquefaction facility for export at an existing import terminal located in Sabine Pass, Texas.  The Golden Pass project also includes proposed modification of an existing pipeline system to enable 2,500 MMcf per day of bidirectional capacity to the proposed export terminal.

These projects demonstrate increased interest in exporting natural gas to overseas markets.  The boom in domestic shale gas production has led to low natural gas prices in the U.S.  Domestic pricing is roughly one-third of the price that exporters can get by sending LNG to Europe or Asia.  Whether and to what extent the U.S. will allow exports remains to be seen, but in the interim, developers are scrambling to secure permits for export. 

New electric generation, mostly fueled by natural gas.  Last month a total of 33 new electric generation units came online.  Nearly three-quarters of the newly installed capacity is fueled by natural gas, adding 2,529 MW of new natural gas-fired electric generating capacity.  The new gas projects vary widely in scope:

• The largest, Mitsubishi Corporation’s 850 MW CPV Sentinel Energy Expansion in Riverside County, consists of eight 106.25 MW units.  Mitsubishi’s generation is sold to Southern California Edison under a long-term contract.
• In the middle, Procter & Gamble Company developed a 64 MW natural gas fired project to produce power for its paper products manufacturing facility in Wyoming County, Pennsylvania.
• At the opposite end of the scale, two landfill gas-fired projects came online in New York.  Wehran Energy Corp.’s 4.5 MW Brookhaven facility consists of three 1.5 MW Caterpillar Inc. generators.  The Brookhaven project was also joined by a 1.6 MW expansion of Waste Management Inc.’s Oneida-Herkimer project.

These projects illustrate the diversity of new natural gas fired projects being developed this spring.  The abundance of low-cost natural gas drives interest in the utility scale gas projects, while a desire to capture landfill-produced methane and put it to use as biogas supports the smaller projects.  As a result, natural gas’s share of total installed operating generating capacity grew slightly to 42.56%.  Despite a resurgence of coal as a fuel for electric generation, coal remains in second place in the installed capacity race, representing 28.9% of total U.S. installed capacity.

While each monthly energy infrastructure update represents only one data point, in the aggregate, they paint a picture of the direction of U.S. energy infrastructure development.  Natural gas is squarely in the center of this picture.  Based on consensus projections that natural gaswill remain the most cost effective fuel for decades to come, increased expansion of natural related infrastructure is likely to continue for some time.

Maine funds available for anaerobic digestion

The state of Maine has announced funds available to help farmers reduce their agricultural impacts to water quality. State agencies have made up to $3 million available to enable low-interest loans to support eligible projects. These projects may include developing anaerobic digesters, as well as improved roof runoff structures, water and sediment control basins, composting facilities, and irrigation system water conservation.

Anaerobic digesters enable the conversion of organic materials such as manure and other agricultural wastes into biogas. Biogas, largely composed of methane, can be used as a fuel source comparable to natural gas. For example, it can be used to power an electric generator and thus to produce renewable electricity – all while making efficient use of manure and agricultural wastes that could otherwise harm water quality.

Two anaerobic digesters at Stonyvale Farm in Exeter, Maine.

Under the program, farmers will be able to borrow up to $450,000 at a fixed interest rate of 2 percent for up to 20 years to develop qualifying projects. The opportunity represents a partnership between the Maine Departments of Environmental Protection and Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry, the Finance Authority of Maine and the Maine Municipal Bond Bank. The initial seed money comes from the DEP-administered Clean Water State Revolving Fund. Since 1989, that fund has provided over $650 million in low-interest loans for water quality projects, primarily hosted by publicly owned wastewater treatment facilities.  For the newly-announced program, the fund will transfer up to $3 million to FAME, which will finance the loans.

For more information on the opportunity, contact either participating department, or consult a professional experienced with anaerobic digestion and state-funded incentive programs. The Preti Flaherty team advises clients on both the development of anaerobic digestion facilities and participation in government-backed loan programs. For more information, please contact Todd Griset at 207-623-5300.

MA net metering expands under new law

Massachusetts legislation signed into law earlier this month provides a variety of incentives for renewable generation in the northeastern US and adjacent Canadian provinces. Senate Bill 2395, An Act relative to competitively priced electricity in the Commonwealth, expands opportunities for net metering, a practice whereby electricity consumers can spin their meters backwards and offset the cost of electricity they buy by producing renewable power themselves.

Under existing Massachusetts law, qualified retail electricity customers who own distributed power generation equipment like solar photovoltaic panels have the right to sell excess power to their local utility at the same retail rates the customers pay to buy power from the utility.  In essence, this allows customers to offset their utility bills for purchasing power by producing more power than the customer needs.  This can be a powerful incentive for customers to develop distributed generation projects, because the retail rates utilities must pay for net metered power are typically higher than the wholesale rates otherwise available to distributed generators.

To limit the size of this incentive, previous law capped net metering to 3% of each utility's historic peak energy load.  Privately-owned equipment like solar panels on businesses or homes was capped at 1% of historic peak load, while publicly-owned facilities (schools, governmental buildings, etc.) were capped at 2%.

The new law doubles the amount of consumer-owned generation eligible for net metering, raising the private and public caps to 3% each.  This amounts to a tripling of the amount of privately-owned distributed generation eligible for net metering.

The law also allows anaerobic digestion to qualify for net metering.  This expansion of eligible technologies is likely to spur the expansion of projects that convert food, farm, and other organic waste to biogas for combustion in engines or turbines connected to electric generators.

An anaerobic digester located on a farm in New England.  The digester breaks organic waste down into biogas that can be used to produce renewable electricity.

As I noted yesterday, the new law also more than doubles the amount of renewable electricity that utilities must purchase from independent generators through long-term power purchase agreements.

USDA funding for biomass energy crops

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has announced $9.6 million in funding for biomass energy crop production in New York, North Carolina and Arkansas. The funding under the Biomass Crop Assistance Program (BCAP) focuses on expanding the production of non-food energy crops for use in manufacturing liquid biofuels and renewable electricity.

Miscsnthus - the dwarf garden variety, related to the giant hybrid energy crop.

BCAP, created in the 2008 Farm Bill, is run by USDA's Farm Service Agency (FSA). BCAP is designed to help farmers and forest land owners switch to crops that can be used to produce usable energy. In many cases, these new energy crops can have significant start-up costs and can take several years before they are ready for harvest. Developing the facilities need to convert these crops into energy products can also involve significant lead time. To overcome these obstacles, BCAP will pay energy crop producers reimbursement for up to 75 percent of the costs of establishing perennial crops. BCAP will also pay for annual maintenance of these crops, for up to five years for herbaceous crops and eleven years for woody crops.

The funding announced this week includes nearly $4 million to fund the production of up to $4,000 acres of grass crops including miscanthus and switchgrass in North Carolina. These crops will be sent to a refinery proposed by Chemtex International where they will be converted into 20 million gallons of bioethanol per year. The refinery is also expected to produce chemicals and biogas. North Carolina farmers will be paid an initial amount to establish the grass crops, plus five years of annual payments for crop maintenance, on top of their crop sales.

$4.2 million in BCAP funding will also support the establishment of up to 3,500 acres of shrub willow in northern New York. Project sponsor ReEnergy Holdings LLC will buy the willow crop as a fuel for biomass electricity production in the area.

BCAP will also provide an additional $1.2 million in funding for an expansion of miscanthus production in northeast Arkansas. Project sponsor MFA Oil Biomass LLC anticipates using the crop to produce a pelletized fuel for both heating use on the producing farms and sale into pellet fuel markets.

Farm waste anaerobic digestion

Yesterday I attended a celebration at Stonyvale Farm in Exeter, Maine, where an innovative anaerobic digester system is now producing renewable electricity from cow manure and other organic waste.  The project demonstrates both a promising technology and an opportunity for farms to produce and market new products.

Two anaerobic digesters at Stonyvale Farm in Exeter, Maine.

Stonyvale Farm is a fifth-generation family dairy farm.  Today the farm is home to 1,000 milk cows and 800 calves.  Several years ago, the family decided to explore the development of an anaerobic digestion system to convert manure and other farm waste to usable biogas.  This led to the creation of Exeter Agri-Energy, a renewable energy company that built and operates a 1-megawatt generator fueled by methane produced through anaerobic digestion at Stonyvale Farm.

Exeter Agri-Energy's digester and generator came online in late 2011.  Today the project converts cow manure and off-farm organic waste from a variety of sources into biogas.  EAE is permitted to accept a variety of food-based and organic wastes from off-farm for conversion into biogas.

The biogas is burned in a combustion engine to produce electricity (enough for about 800 homes) and heat.  I helped the company qualify the project for incentives under Maine's community-based renewable energy pilot program, which gives Exeter Agri-Energy a long-term contract to sell the facility’s output to its local transmission and distribution utility for up to 20 years at average prices up to $100 per MWh (equivalent to 10¢ per kWh).  This works much like a feed-in tariff for qualified projects, giving them a guaranteed buyer and price for the project's output.

Fuel production on the farm: dairy cows at Stonyvale Farm.

This on-farm energy project also enables the creation of additional products and revenue streams, as well as cutting the farm's costs.  Byproducts of the digestion process become organic fertilizer, organic soil additives, and animal bedding used on the farm, creating a variety of products with minimal waste.

Biogas at Apple's NC data center

Continuing to look at Apple's plans for energy supply at its data center in Maiden, North Carolina:

This spring a series of filings by Apple to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission gave the public some insight into Apple's planned electric generation facilities at the Maiden data center, home to Apple's iCloud service.  (See Tuesday's blog entry for a look at its solar photovoltaic project, and Wednesday's entry for its fuel cell project.)

Fuel cells convert fuels into electricity through a chemical process that does not rely on combustion.  According to one of Apple's filings with FERC, Apple plans to use biogas to power its fuel cells:

The Systems will be fueled with biogas that will be transported via a natural gas pipeline system.  To be injected into the natural gas pipeline system and qualify as pipeline-grade gas, biogas must meet strict heat content and quality requirements.  Consequently, raw biogas must be upgraded (i.e., cleaned and separated to remove components such as hydrogen sulfide, chlorine, and sulfur and to increase methane content) prior to being injected into a pipeline.  Once injected into the pipeline system, it comingles with conventional natural gas and is indistinguishable from conventional natural gas in terms of safety and burning quality.  The biogas, having been upgraded/cleaned to pipeline-quality and then injected into the natural gas pipeline system displaces a comparable quantity of conventional natural gas.
The volume and heat content of the biogas will be measured at a utility-grade meter at the point of injection.  The biogas will then enter the natural gas pipeline infrastructure that has an established balancing measurement system regulated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Commission).  The biogas will be nominated for the Facility in accordance with the pipeline’s posted business practices and relevant Commission requirements.  Not only the contract and purchase of biogas, but also the nomination process demonstrates compliance with 18 C.F.R. § 292.204 (b).  A utility-grade meter at the Facility will measure actual gas consumption by the Facility.  A revenue-grade meter will measure electricity generated by the Facility.

Furthermore, because the biogas can be upgraded to flow in a pipeline system and nominated for a particular facility, it allows for flexibility in the location of the generating unit.  This flexibility will provide for increased efficiency (operational and maintenance), enhanced reliability, and improved land use. These benefits were recognized by the North Carolina Utilities Commission (“NCUC”).  The NCUC ruled that biogas fuel, which is derived from a renewable energy resource, cleaned to pipeline quality, injected into the pipeline system and nominated for an electric generation facility within the state of North Carolina, is a renewable energy resource known as “Directed Biogas” (NCUC Order Issued March 21, 2012, in docket SP 100, Sub 29). 

This Facility is in keeping with the stated reasons for the implementation of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978 (PURPA), specifically the increased conservation of electric energy, increased efficiency in the use of facility and resources by electric utilities, and the conservation of natural gas.  In the case of this Facility, the use of biogas, which displaces conventional natural gas, to generate electricity will reduce greenhouse gas emissions and smog forming pollutants while also diversifying the fuel used to generate electricity.  The Systems that make up this Facility consume less fuel and produce less CO2 than other technologies.  Each System emits less than 0.07 lbs/MW-hr of NOx , negligible SOx, less than 0.10 lbs/MW-hr of CO and less than 0.02 lbs/MW-hr of VOC.  Additionally, the Systems require very little water, with an average usage of approximately 0.00001 gallons/kWh. The low carbon footprint, de minimus criteria pollutants, small land use and negligible water use, make this Facility a prime example of an initiative that furthers the Commission’s stated goal of increasing renewable energy and investing in environmentally beneficial technologies.

Apple's Maiden, NC fuel cell project

Following on yesterday's look at Apple's planned solar photovoltaic system for its Maiden, North Carolina data center, here's a look at the fuel cell project Apple is also planning the Maiden facility.

A public filing Apple made last month to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission describes the Maiden data center's proposed fuel cell system.  The filing represents Apple's self-certification that the fuel cell project meets the standards of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) of 1978 as a "qualifying facility", setting the facility up for incentives that could include the right to require Duke Energy Carolinas to buy its output.

Apple's fuel cell self-certification filing, docketed by FERC as QF12-327, describes the project:

The Facility will consist of 24 fuel cell systems (“Systems”) using a patented solid oxide fuel cell technology to generate electricity.  A single fuel cell consists of an anode, a cathode and an electrolyte placed between the two electrodes.  As fuel flows in through the anode side and an oxidant comes in over the cathode, a reaction is triggered that causes electrons to move into the fuel cell’s circuit, producing electricity.

Each System consists of thousands of fuel cells stacked together.  Multiple stacks are aggregated together into a "power module", and then multiple power modules, along with a common fuel input and electrical output are assembled as a complete system.  Each System is approximately the size of a standard parking space and will produce approximately 200 kW of power.  The Systems have a modular design that allows the simultaneous use of multiple Systems in order to achieve the desired electric generation output.  Each 200 kW (AC) System is comprised of six individual direct current (DC) power-producing modules and one input/output module for fuel intake and electricity output.  Each of the six individual DC power producing modules is feeding electricity to the input/output module which converts the DC power into the systems AC power output.  The combination of six DC modules and one input/output module comprise a 200 kW (AC) all-electric System.  Each System has a net baseload generating capacity of 200 kW (AC).  The total generating capacity of the Facility will be approximately 4.8 MW (AC).

The "patented solid oxide fuel cell technology to generate electricity" in this description is reported to be Bloom Energy's Bloom box technology.

Tomorrow, a look at the innovative fuel Apple proposes to use to power these fuel cells.

Apple's Maiden NC solar project

As Apple continues to develop a data center to handle its iCloud service, some details are emerging about the energy infrastructure to be built at the Maiden, North Carolina facility.  Two public filings Apple made last month to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission describe the Maiden data center's solar photovoltaic and fuel cell systems.

Under federal law, certain efficient or renewable electricity generation facilities can certify themselves as "qualifying facilities" or QFs.  The Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) of 1978 required monopolistic electric utilities to buy power from QFs, as long as that cost was less than the utility's own "avoided cost".  Generally, a utility's avoided cost is the cost of the power the utility would have procured from a source other than the QF in question.  This policy was intended to improve the efficiency of the nation's fleet of electric generation, as lower-cost QFs displaced more expensive traditional utility generation.

In April, Apple submitted two filings to FERC certifying its planned Maiden solar and fuel cell systems as QFs.  These documents provide additional insight into Apple's plans.

In its solar photovoltaic project self-certification, docketed by FERC as QF12-328, Apple described the project:

Each of the photovoltaic installations will consist of multiple 435-watt photovoltaic modules on ground-mounted single-axis tracking systems. The current design includes 57,360 435-watt modules. The modules will be connected in series strings of 10 to achieve the appropriate DC voltage. The modules will track the sun by rotating about a north-south axis. At the current time, we expect 14 photovoltaic installations will make up the solar farm: ten 1.50 MW installations and four 1.25 MW installations. The final number of installations and modules will depend on detailed design considerations in consultation with the utility, the photovoltaic system provider, and local permitting authorities. Each installation will be connected to two 750 kW or two 625 kW inverters. Inverters will convert the DC current produced by the systems to AC current. A step up transformer is installed between the inverter outputs and the point of connection to Duke's distribution system. Each installation has a dedicated transformer. The photovoltaic installations will be installed in a phased manner, whereby the installations will be interconnected as they are completed.

Check out tomorrow's blog entry for a look at Apple's biogas fuel cell facility.

Debate over data center green claims

How green is Apple's iCloud data storage service?  That question provoked debate this week, as environmental activism group Greenpeace released a report critical of Apple's choices of power supply for its data center in Maiden, North Carolina, where the iCloud storage is based.

Greenpeace's report, How Clean is Your Cloud (52-page PDF), notes the explosive growth of cloud-based data and computing services offered by companies like Apple, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft, Google,
and Yahoo.  These services are made possible by data centers, centralized networks of servers and computer infrastructure.  As Greenpeace put it, "Data centers are the factories of the 21st century information age, containing thousands of computers that store and manage our rapidly growing collection of data for consumption at a moment’s notice."

Data centers can be major consumers of electricity, needing cooling and air handling as well as energy for raw processing operations.  Some data center operators seek out renewable electricity, while others are developing on-site generation.  Most work to improve their energy efficiency, making the best possible use of the energy they need.

Apple has touted the green credentials of its Maiden data center, which was designed to earn LEED Platinum certification from the U.S. Green Building Council.  Apple's Maiden facility will also include a 20 MW solar facility on land adjacent to the data center, as well as a 5 MW biogas-based fuel cell system, systems Apple describes as "the nation’s largest end user-owned solar array" and "the largest nonutility fuel cell installation in the United States."

Greenpeace's report notes that despite these investments, Apple's data center is located in an area where utilities source a significant amount of power from coal-fired power plants.  Greenpeace and Apple dispute how much power the Maiden plant will consume (differing by as much as a factor of 5), and thus what fraction of its electricity will be produced from renewable on-site generation.

Whatever the facts may be, the debate illustrates society's interest in the environmental impacts of our technological choices - as well as the difficulty in evaluating some claims of greenness.