The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has released a document answering "Frequently Asked Questions" about the removal of obsolete dams.
As noted by EPA, dams "provide important
societal
functions for drinking water
supply, flood control, hydropower
generation,
and recreation." EPA estimates that the U.S. is home to between 2,000,000 and 2,500,000 dams -- but that between 75% and 90% of these dams "no longer serve a functional purpose." Given the expense of maintaining dams and their safety, and some negative social and environmental impacts of dams, there is some pressure to remove obsolete dams. According to EPA, over 1,300 dams have been removed in the U.S. since the early 1900s, with over 60 removals in 2015 alone.
EPA framed its dam removal FAQ in this context, noting that its answers to these questions would support dam removal efforts. The FAQ addresses 20 distinct topics, ranging from dams' impacts on water quality, permitting issues related to dam removal, and EPA-related funding that could be used to support dam removal.
For example, the FAQ discusses permitting under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act, including the use of individual permits or general permits, including Nationwide Permits. The FAQ encourages project proponents to work closely with the Army Corps of Engineers regarding Section 404 permitting. It describes how EPA would evaluate specific requirements for monitoring or testing, such as in the case of contaminated sediments behind the dam. The FAQ also discusses other permitting requirements, such as state-issued water quality certifications pursuant to Section 401 of the Clean Water Act, and evaluations of consistency with coastal zone management plans under the Coastal Zone Management Act.
The FAQ also notes that various grants may be available for dam removal projects. For example, grants under Section 319 of the Clean Water Act can be issued to states, territories, and tribes for dam removals. EPA's Five Star Wetland and Urban Water Restoration Grant Program could also provide funding for river, wetlands, riparian, forest and coastal restoration, and wildlife conservation. Other funding, such as under the Wetland Program Development Grant program, is available to build technical and programmatic capacity of state and tribal water agencies. Finally, the FAQ notes that dam removals could be part of a Supplemental Environmental Project proposed in settlement of an environmental enforcement action.
As noted by EPA, the FAQs released in December 2016 do not impose legally binding requirements on anyone, and EPA retains the discretion to adopt
approaches on a case-by-case basis that differ from those described in these FAQs where appropriate. Nevertheless the document provides dam owners, regulators, and communities guidance on how EPA views dam removal proposals.
Showing posts with label Clean Water Act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Clean Water Act. Show all posts
EPA FAQ on dam removal projects
Friday, January 6, 2017
Labels:
Clean Water Act,
dam,
dam removal,
enforcement,
EPA,
funding,
grant,
hydropower,
mitigation,
Section 401,
Section 404,
settlement,
water quality,
wetland
EPA regs and electric grid reliability
Wednesday, November 30, 2011
Debate is ongoing about the effect of new environmental regulations on the U.S. electric grid. Some worry that tighter environmental controls will force certain electric generators to shut down, driving up the cost of electricity or putting electric reliability at risk. Others believe that the grid's integrity can be maintained, and that the new regulations are necessary to protect human health and the environment.
Support for the concerned side of the equation comes from a recent report by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation. NERC is the nation's electric reliability organization, charged with ensuring the reliability of the North American bulk power system. In NERC's 2011 Long-Term Reliability Assessment (559 page PDF), NERC notes that recent and future environmental regulations may force the early retirement of a significant portion of the nation's coal-fired generating plants. These regulations include the recently-finalized Cross-State Air Pollution Rule, plus rules under development governing utility plants' water intakes and air emissions. According to NERC's report, EPA's new cooling water intake structures and mercury and air toxics standards rules "may significantly affect bulk power system reliability depending on the scope and timing of the rule implementation and the mechanisms in place to preserve reliability."
At the same time, others observe that NERC's report assumes multiple worst-case scenarios and ignored the health and environmental benefits of the rules. After reviewing a near-final draft of the NERC report, EPA itself wrote NERC a letter (4 page PDF), stating "it appears likely your report may contain ... faulty characterizations of our rules." EPA pointed to several flaws in NERC's analysis, including that NERC assumed generators would be forced to adopt the most expensive solutions immediately, rather than selecting the most cost-effective technologies for each facility. EPA noted that the bulk of threatened plant retirements suggested in NERC's report would come from the cooling water intake regulations -- regulations which are still under development. Finally, EPA pointed out that NERC's analysis appears to assume that no one tries to preserve grid reliability as the regulations begin to take effect, "an outcome that flies in the face of our 40 years of implementing the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act." Given the positive impacts of the regulations -- with the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule alone projected to prevent 34,000 premature deaths and 400,000 cases of aggravated asthma per year -- EPA defended their value and refuted NERC's analysis.
Reliability of the grid is important, enough so that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission convened a technical conference yesterday and today to discuss grid reliability and policy. While that proceeding may result in interim orders or changes to policy, it may take years for the environmental regulations to both take effect and to impact generating plants. At the same time, generators are keeping a close watch on federal environmental regulation as it develops.
Support for the concerned side of the equation comes from a recent report by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation. NERC is the nation's electric reliability organization, charged with ensuring the reliability of the North American bulk power system. In NERC's 2011 Long-Term Reliability Assessment (559 page PDF), NERC notes that recent and future environmental regulations may force the early retirement of a significant portion of the nation's coal-fired generating plants. These regulations include the recently-finalized Cross-State Air Pollution Rule, plus rules under development governing utility plants' water intakes and air emissions. According to NERC's report, EPA's new cooling water intake structures and mercury and air toxics standards rules "may significantly affect bulk power system reliability depending on the scope and timing of the rule implementation and the mechanisms in place to preserve reliability."
At the same time, others observe that NERC's report assumes multiple worst-case scenarios and ignored the health and environmental benefits of the rules. After reviewing a near-final draft of the NERC report, EPA itself wrote NERC a letter (4 page PDF), stating "it appears likely your report may contain ... faulty characterizations of our rules." EPA pointed to several flaws in NERC's analysis, including that NERC assumed generators would be forced to adopt the most expensive solutions immediately, rather than selecting the most cost-effective technologies for each facility. EPA noted that the bulk of threatened plant retirements suggested in NERC's report would come from the cooling water intake regulations -- regulations which are still under development. Finally, EPA pointed out that NERC's analysis appears to assume that no one tries to preserve grid reliability as the regulations begin to take effect, "an outcome that flies in the face of our 40 years of implementing the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act." Given the positive impacts of the regulations -- with the Cross-State Air Pollution Rule alone projected to prevent 34,000 premature deaths and 400,000 cases of aggravated asthma per year -- EPA defended their value and refuted NERC's analysis.
Reliability of the grid is important, enough so that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission convened a technical conference yesterday and today to discuss grid reliability and policy. While that proceeding may result in interim orders or changes to policy, it may take years for the environmental regulations to both take effect and to impact generating plants. At the same time, generators are keeping a close watch on federal environmental regulation as it develops.
July 19, 2010 - life on a Maine island
Monday, July 19, 2010
I've just returned from a visit to one of Maine's offshore islands. Life on a small island can seem fundamentally different: the pace of life is driven by the tides and boat schedules, and fog can often replace the mainland's heat. It was a good place to think about energy policy, and history, and where we can go from here.
More updates to follow regularly.
Brief news recap:
Friends of Merrymeeting Bay (FOMB) have provided 60-day notice of intent to sue the owners of four Maine dams under the Clean Water Act over issues relating to Atlantic salmon. FOMB have a history of legal activism over fish (including eel) passage at dams in Maine, particularly in the Merrymeeting Bay watershed. If you've read my earlier posts about kayaking in Merrymeeting Bay, you might know that Merrymeeting Bay is where the Androscoggin River flows into the Kennebec. FOMB has identified four dams in its threat: the Lockwood Dam in Waterville, "Hydro Kennebec" in Winslow, Shawmut Dam in Fairfield and Weston Dam in Skowhegan.
More updates to follow regularly.
Brief news recap:
Friends of Merrymeeting Bay (FOMB) have provided 60-day notice of intent to sue the owners of four Maine dams under the Clean Water Act over issues relating to Atlantic salmon. FOMB have a history of legal activism over fish (including eel) passage at dams in Maine, particularly in the Merrymeeting Bay watershed. If you've read my earlier posts about kayaking in Merrymeeting Bay, you might know that Merrymeeting Bay is where the Androscoggin River flows into the Kennebec. FOMB has identified four dams in its threat: the Lockwood Dam in Waterville, "Hydro Kennebec" in Winslow, Shawmut Dam in Fairfield and Weston Dam in Skowhegan.
Labels:
Androscoggin,
Clean Water Act,
dams,
eel,
Fairfield,
fish passage,
Hydro Kennebec,
Kennebec,
lawsuit,
Lockwood Dam,
Merrymeeting Bay,
salmon,
Shawmut,
Skowhegan,
Weston,
Winslow
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
